Are All Pandemics Caused by Animals? Not Quite

Not all pandemics are caused by animals, but the majority are. Around 60% of emerging infectious diseases reported globally are zoonotic, meaning they originated in animals before jumping to humans. Of new human pathogens detected in the last three decades, 75% came from animal sources. That leaves a significant minority of pandemic-capable diseases that spread through water, soil, or purely human-to-human transmission with no animal reservoir at all.

What “Caused by Animals” Actually Means

When scientists say a disease is zoonotic, they mean the pathogen lived in an animal population first and then crossed the species barrier into humans. This crossing, called spillover, isn’t random. It depends on how many infected animals are concentrated in an area, how much pathogen they shed into the environment through feces, saliva, or blood, and whether humans have close enough contact to encounter it. Deforestation, farming practices, and wildlife trade all increase the odds by putting people and animals in tighter quarters.

Bats are particularly notable reservoirs because their immune systems tolerate a wide variety of viruses without getting sick, they live in enormous colonies, and they frequently share environments with humans and livestock. But rodents, primates, birds, and domestic animals all serve as reservoirs for different pathogens.

Major Pandemics That Came From Animals

The 1918 influenza pandemic, which killed an estimated 50 million people, originated when a human flu virus picked up seven of its eight gene segments from a bird virus around 1915. That single reassortment event created a hybrid pathogen humans had no immunity against. Later flu pandemics in 1957, 1968, and 2009 followed a similar pattern, with avian or swine flu genes mixing with human-adapted strains.

HIV, the virus behind the AIDS pandemic, traces back to a simian virus found in a subspecies of chimpanzee called Pan troglodytes troglodytes in Central Africa. The virus crossed into humans at least twice, producing different groups of HIV-1. HIV-2, a less widespread form, came from a different primate entirely: the sooty mangabey monkey. Both crossovers likely happened through hunting and butchering of bushmeat.

Bubonic plague, which killed roughly a third of Europe’s population in the 14th century, is caused by a bacterium that cycles naturally among wild rodents and spreads to humans through flea bites. Dense rat populations in medieval cities created ideal conditions for explosive outbreaks. The last urban plague outbreak in the United States hit Los Angeles in 1924.

COVID-19 fits the pattern as well. While the precise intermediate host remains debated, SARS-CoV-2 is closely related to coronaviruses found in bats, consistent with the zoonotic origins of the original SARS virus in 2003 and MERS in 2012.

Pandemics With No Animal Origin

Cholera has caused seven recognized pandemics since 1817, and none of them required an animal host. The bacterium lives in brackish and coastal waters and spreads when people drink contaminated water or eat contaminated food. Large outbreaks are typically tied to poor sanitation, contaminated water supplies, or food from street vendors. While raw shellfish can carry the bacterium, the shellfish aren’t a reservoir in the way bats or rodents are for viruses. They’re simply a vehicle.

Smallpox, one of the deadliest diseases in human history, was exclusively a human pathogen. It had no animal reservoir whatsoever. The same is true of polio. Both viruses spread only from person to person, which is precisely what made their eradication (or near-eradication, in polio’s case) theoretically possible. If a virus can hide in an animal population and jump back into humans later, eliminating it from people alone isn’t enough.

Tuberculosis offers a more nuanced case. Modern TB is caused by a bacterium whose ancestors were human-restricted. All members of the tuberculosis complex descend from a single human-adapted ancestor. The cattle form of the disease, often assumed to be the original source, actually evolved more recently and is the newest member of the family. So TB didn’t jump from cows to people. It went the other direction.

Environmental Reservoirs Beyond Animals

Some infectious agents live in soil or water rather than in any animal host. Fungal diseases like histoplasmosis originate from organisms that multiply in soil. Legionnaires’ disease outbreaks are traced to water in cooling towers and air conditioning systems, where the bacterium thrives. Hookworm spreads through direct contact with contaminated soil. These pathogens don’t need an animal to reach humans. They simply need the right environmental conditions.

None of these environmental pathogens have caused pandemics on the scale of influenza or plague, but they demonstrate that the animal-to-human pathway isn’t the only route. Water, soil, and human-built infrastructure can all serve as launching points for outbreaks.

Why Animal Origins Dominate

The reason most pandemics trace back to animals is partly a numbers game. Wildlife harbors an enormous diversity of viruses, bacteria, and parasites, many of which humans have never been exposed to and have no immunity against. When one of these pathogens develops the ability to infect human cells and then spread between people, it can move through an immunologically naive population with devastating speed.

Pathogens that have circulated in humans for centuries, like cholera or smallpox, tend to be better understood and more predictable. The biggest surprises, the ones that trigger new pandemics, almost always come from the animal world simply because that’s where the vast majority of unknown pathogens live. The WHO estimates that hundreds of thousands of viruses in mammals and birds have the potential to infect humans. Only a tiny fraction ever will, but the ones that do tend to define eras.

So while animals are responsible for the majority of pandemic threats, they aren’t responsible for all of them. Contaminated water, environmental bacteria, and strictly human-adapted viruses have all caused widespread devastation without any animal involvement. The pattern is clear but not absolute.