A common concern for anyone who discovers unexpected swelling in the scrotum is the fear of malignancy. This worry is understandable, as testicular cancer is a serious condition requiring prompt attention. This article clarifies the connection between a hydrocele, a common cause of scrotal swelling, and the possibility of cancer.
Understanding What a Hydrocele Is
A hydrocele is a type of scrotal swelling that occurs when fluid collects within the thin, sac-like layer surrounding the testicle, known as the tunica vaginalis. This accumulation of serous fluid causes the scrotum to enlarge, typically resulting in a smooth, soft, and fluctuant mass that is usually painless. The condition is not a solid mass of tissue and can affect one or both sides of the scrotum.
In infants, hydroceles are frequently congenital, stemming from the failure of the processus vaginalis (a small channel) to close completely after the testicles descend. This open channel allows fluid from the abdominal cavity to flow into the scrotum, creating a communicating hydrocele that may change size throughout the day.
In older children and adults, hydroceles are generally acquired, resulting from an imbalance in fluid production and absorption. Common causes include trauma, inflammation, or infection within the testicle or epididymis. These are often noncommunicating hydroceles, meaning the channel has sealed, but the fluid has not been reabsorbed.
Clarifying the Cancer Risk
A hydrocele itself is a benign condition and does not represent a cancerous growth. The fluid collection is not made of malignant cells and cannot transform into testicular cancer. Hydroceles and testicular cancers are two separate conditions with different underlying causes and cellular compositions.
Confusion exists because both conditions often present initially as a painless swelling in the scrotum, prompting medical evaluation. While the hydrocele is benign, it can sometimes form secondarily to an underlying problem, such as an infection or, in rare cases, a testicular tumor. A tumor can irritate the surrounding tissue, leading to a small reactive hydrocele.
The primary risk associated with a hydrocele is that a large one can obscure a healthcare provider’s ability to palpate the testicle. This makes it difficult to detect a small, solid lump or mass on the testicle that could be an early sign of malignancy. Therefore, any new or unexplained scrotal swelling requires a professional medical assessment to ensure that a serious underlying condition is not missed.
Medical Evaluation and Differentiation
The first step in evaluating scrotal swelling is a thorough physical examination to assess the size, location, and consistency of the mass. A classic test used is transillumination, where a light source is held against the scrotum. Because a hydrocele is a purely fluid-filled sac, the light will pass through the fluid and illuminate the entire mass, which is a distinguishing feature.
In contrast, a solid tumor, characteristic of testicular cancer, will block the light and not transilluminate. However, a physical exam alone is not always enough to definitively rule out a tumor, especially if a large hydrocele makes the testicle difficult to feel. The hydrocele mass is often described as non-tender and smooth, whereas a cancerous mass is typically firm and fixed within the testicular tissue.
The definitive diagnostic tool for distinguishing a hydrocele from testicular cancer is a scrotal ultrasound with Doppler imaging. Ultrasound uses sound waves to create a precise image of the structures, clearly showing the difference between a fluid collection and a solid mass. A hydrocele appears as an anechoic (dark) fluid collection surrounding the testicle, while a testicular tumor appears as a solid mass with an irregular texture and sometimes increased blood flow.
Treatment Options for a Hydrocele
For many hydroceles, particularly in infants or small, asymptomatic ones in adults, the recommended approach is watchful waiting, as they can resolve spontaneously. If the hydrocele does not cause significant discomfort, is not large, and the testicle is clearly identifiable as healthy, this conservative management is preferred. Regular monitoring ensures the condition is not growing or causing complications.
When the hydrocele becomes large, causes pain, or creates a cosmetic concern, intervention may be necessary. One procedure is aspiration, which involves draining the fluid using a needle. This method provides temporary relief, but the fluid often reaccumulates because the underlying sac remains intact.
For a more permanent solution, a surgical procedure called a hydrocelectomy is performed. During this operation, the surgeon removes the hydrocele sac or reverses the sac to prevent the future buildup of fluid. This procedure is the standard treatment for hydroceles that are symptomatic or persistent.

