How Do Fish Have Sex? From Spawning to Sex Change

For most fish, sex involves no penetration and no contact inside the body. Eggs and sperm meet in open water, outside both parents. Some fish do mate internally, and a few carry or even feed their young inside their bodies the way mammals do. The line between male and female is also far less fixed in fish than in mammals, since some species switch sex partway through life.

How Most Fish Fertilize Eggs Outside the Body

Most fish species reproduce by releasing unfertilized eggs that the male fertilizes in the water, a process called spawning.1Necropsy Manual. Teleosts In many reef fish, a pair rises up through the water together, touches bellies for a few seconds, and shimmies.2Reefs.com. Spawn Watch: How to witness pelagic spawning reef fish The shimmy lets each fish time its release of eggs or sperm to match its partner’s.2Reefs.com. Spawn Watch: How to witness pelagic spawning reef fish Then the pair darts apart, and a flick of the tail scatters the fertilized eggs into the water.2Reefs.com. Spawn Watch: How to witness pelagic spawning reef fish Timing matters because sperm in open water spreads out and loses its ability to swim within moments, so releasing even a little early or late leaves many eggs unfertilized. A few species, such as some nest-builders, have the female lay first and the male follow.

In an aquarium or pond, spawning often looks like chasing, quivering, or pairs pressing their sides together. Some species spawn in big groups all at once instead of in pairs. Eggs may end up stuck to plants, glass, or gravel, or they may drift away. Many adult fish eat scattered eggs, so keepers often remove the eggs or the adults.

Open-water eggs face many losses. Some go unfertilized, some drift off, and some get eaten before they hatch. Many spawning fish compensate by releasing huge numbers of eggs, so a few survivors are enough to continue the line. Internal fertilizers usually produce fewer young because eggs kept inside the body are better protected.

Fish That Mate Internally or Give Live Birth

Male sharks have a mating organ called a clasper on each pelvic fin.3sharks4kids.com. Shark Reproduction The male inserts a clasper into the female’s single body opening and releases sperm to fertilize her eggs.3sharks4kids.com. Shark Reproduction Livebearing aquarium fish such as guppies and mollies use a modified anal fin in the same role.

What happens next varies. Some internally fertilized fish release fertilized eggs or early embryos into the water, often wrapped in a tough outer layer.4Wikipedia. Fish reproduction In others, the eggs stay and develop inside the mother but live only on their own yolk, getting little or nothing from her.4Wikipedia. Fish reproduction In true livebearers, the mother feeds the young directly, and there are two types depending on how the nutrients reach them.4Wikipedia. Fish reproduction

The leathery “mermaid’s purses” that wash up on beaches are egg cases from internally fertilized skates and some sharks. The embryo grows inside for months on its yolk before hatching, so an empty case usually means the young have already left.

If you keep livebearers, know that females can already be pregnant when you buy them, so surprise babies are common. The fry are born swimming and can hide right away. Adults often eat newborns, so dense plants or a separate tank help more of them survive.

How Fish Attract a Mate and Who Wins the Eggs

Fish use chemical signals to reproduce.5PubMed Central. Pheromone Perception in Fish: Mechanisms and Modulation by Internal Status In Mozambique tilapia, male urine contains a chemical that draws females to the nest and speeds the ripening of their eggs.6Max Planck Society. Ready for mating at the right time The same urine calms aggression in rival males.6Max Planck Society. Ready for mating at the right time So the male’s scent helps the female be ready to spawn exactly when he is.6Max Planck Society. Ready for mating at the right time Female zebrafish are drawn more by male scent than by the sight of males, and the two together work best.7Aquaculture and Fisheries. Male zebrafish (Danio rerio) odorants attract females and induce spawning

Scent works well in murky or crowded water because it travels without a clear line of sight. It can also linger after the sender has moved on, letting a female detect that a male has been in the area.

Sound and color play a part too. Male African cichlids make pulsing sounds while quivering during courtship, and they choose when to make them.8PubMed Central. The African Cichlid Fish Astatotilapia burtoni Uses Acoustic Communication for Reproduction: Sound Production, Hearing, and Behavioral Significance Zebrafish of both sexes change their stripe colors during spawning, and the most colorful males court the most.9Ethology. Ephemeral sexual dichromatism in zebrafish (Danio rerio)

In a tank or pond, look for males brightening in color in the days before spawning. Quivering, circling, or a male repeatedly leading a female toward one spot are typical. Some species make faint grunts or clicks that a hydrophone can pick up.

Female choice doesn’t end when the eggs are released. The fluid that surrounds a female’s eggs, called ovarian fluid, makes sperm swim faster and straighter.10PubMed Central. Ovarian fluid allows directional cryptic female choice despite external fertilization When two males’ sperm compete, speed then matters more and sheer sperm number matters less.10PubMed Central. Ovarian fluid allows directional cryptic female choice despite external fertilization In chinook salmon, the male whose sperm swam fastest in a female’s fluid fertilized more eggs, and those embryos survived better.11PubMed Central. Cryptic female choice enhances fertilization success and embryo survival in chinook salmon So even with fertilization in open water, females keep some say over who fathers their young.10PubMed Central. Ovarian fluid allows directional cryptic female choice despite external fertilization

When Fish Spawn and Who Guards the Eggs

Walleye spawn in response to both water temperature and day length together.12Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences. Understanding shifting cues for walleye spawning phenology and recruitment in a changing climate They don’t simply move earlier when ice melts sooner. Lake sturgeon time their run upriver by water temperature, river flow, and the phase of the moon.13PubMed. Environmental and lunar cues are predictive of the timing of river entry and spawning-site arrival in lake sturgeon Acipenser fulvescens

Spawning at the right time means young hatch when food is available. Day length is the same from year to year while temperature varies, so using both gives a more reliable signal than either alone.

For anglers and keepers, spring warming and lengthening days are when many freshwater fish move to shallow spawning areas. Many places close fishing seasons during spawning to protect guarding males. Keepers often trigger spawning by slowly raising the temperature or doing a cool water change.

Among fish whose eggs sink and stick in place, it’s usually the male who cares for them.14PubMed Central. Nest-site selection in a fish species with paternal care He builds a nest or claims a burrow, and females come to spawn in it.14PubMed Central. Nest-site selection in a fish species with paternal care He guards the eggs from predators, often other fish of his own kind, fans them with fresh water, and removes diseased eggs.14PubMed Central. Nest-site selection in a fish species with paternal care Males in one species chose warmer, more oxygen-rich nest spots.14PubMed Central. Nest-site selection in a fish species with paternal care

A male hovering over a nest and waving his fins isn’t sick. Steady fanning pushes oxygen to the eggs, and he may chase away much larger fish. Remove him and egg predators often wipe out the nest.

How Fish Change Sex

Clownfish start life as males, and which fish becomes female depends on its social rank and size.15PubMed Central. Transcriptome Profiling and Expression Localization of Key Sex-Related Genes in a Socially-Controlled Hermaphroditic Clownfish, Amphiprion clarkii When the group’s female is removed, the largest male begins turning female.16PubMed Central. Sex Change in Clownfish: Molecular Insights from Transcriptome Analysis His testes shrink as ovary tissue grows, reaching about 87% ovary 40 days after the female is lost.16PubMed Central. Sex Change in Clownfish: Molecular Insights from Transcriptome Analysis Hormone signals that drive reproduction rise steadily as the change proceeds.17PubMed. Expression of three gonadotropin subunits and gonadotropin receptor mRNA during male-to-female sex change in the cinnamon clownfish, Amphiprion melanopus

In the wild, a clownfish group has one breeding pair plus smaller non-breeding males waiting in line. So the “Finding Nemo” version is off: if the mother were lost, the father would become the female, not find a new mate.

For clownfish owners, two juveniles bought together will usually sort out into a female and a male, with the larger, more dominant fish becoming the female. The change takes weeks to months, not days. Adding a third clownfish may lead to fighting over rank.

Many wrasses do the reverse, starting female and becoming male. Cortisol, a stress hormone, can trigger female-to-male change in wrasses and rises naturally early in the switch in some gobies.18PubMed Central. Effects of cortisol on female-to-male sex change in a wrasse

Sex change is favored when being big benefits one sex much more than the other.19PubMed. A comparative analysis of sex change in Labridae supports the size advantage hypothesis In species where one large male controls a group of females, it pays to breed as a female while small and as a male once large.20PubMed. A phylogenetic test of the size-advantage model: evolutionary changes in mating behavior influence the loss of sex change in a fish lineage But when many males spawn together and compete with sperm, female-to-male change becomes less useful.20PubMed. A phylogenetic test of the size-advantage model: evolutionary changes in mating behavior influence the loss of sex change in a fish lineage

Strange Strategies From Egg Trading to Male Pregnancy

Some sea basses are both male and female at the same time.21Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie. Egg Trading in the Chalk Bass, Serranus tortugarum, a Simultaneous Hermaphrodite Pairs take turns, each giving up some eggs for the other to fertilize in exchange for fertilizing the partner’s eggs.21Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie. Egg Trading in the Chalk Bass, Serranus tortugarum, a Simultaneous Hermaphrodite It’s a rare, well-documented case of animals trading fairly with unrelated partners.22PubMed. The Evolution of Egg Trading in Simultaneous Hermaphrodites Taking turns means each fish must keep giving to keep getting.

In seahorses, the female deposits eggs in the male’s pouch. The pouch lining develops a blood-rich, placenta-like layer that passes oxygen and nutrients to the young and removes waste.23PubMed Central. Seahorse Male Pregnancy as a Model System to Study Pregnancy, Immune Adaptations, and Environmental Effects

In some deep-sea anglerfish, tiny males attach permanently to much larger females, and their bodies fuse into a shared blood supply.24PubMed Central. Histocompatibility and Reproduction: Lessons from the Anglerfish In the dark, vast deep sea, males and females rarely meet, so staying attached guarantees a mate.24PubMed Central. Histocompatibility and Reproduction: Lessons from the Anglerfish The female’s body doesn’t reject the male, unlike nearly any other vertebrate.24PubMed Central. Histocompatibility and Reproduction: Lessons from the Anglerfish That is because these anglerfish have lost key parts of their immune system.25PubMed. Deep sea evolution: Glowing lures, parasitic males and rapid speciation in anglerfishes

Not every male plays fair. In some species, small “sneaker” males dart in to steal fertilizations from nesting males. Nesting males tend to release fewer but faster sperm, which ovarian fluid favors.10PubMed Central. Ovarian fluid allows directional cryptic female choice despite external fertilization

Births can happen without fathers too. A female hammerhead shark in captivity produced a pup with no male, a virgin birth.26PubMed Central. Virgin birth in a hammerhead shark But such pups get genes from only the mother, which reduces genetic variety.26PubMed Central. Virgin birth in a hammerhead shark

How Warmer Water Can Change a Fish’s Sex

In European sea bass, raising water temperature during a critical early period can produce an all-male group.27PLoS Genetics. Molecular Mechanism Links Temperature With Sex Determination in Some Fish Species Heat switches off a gene needed to make female hormones in some genetic females.27PLoS Genetics. Molecular Mechanism Links Temperature With Sex Determination in Some Fish Species In zebrafish, high temperatures usually push fish toward male, but how strongly depends on the family.28PubMed Central. Heat-induced masculinization in domesticated zebrafish is family-specific and yields a set of different gonadal transcriptomes Many species, including zebrafish and medaka, don’t truly have their sex set by temperature.29PubMed Central. Temperature-Dependent Sex Determination in Fish Revisited: Prevalence, a Single Sex Ratio Response Pattern, and Possible Effects of Climate Change

The critical period is a limited window early in development. After it closes, warming no longer changes the fish’s sex in the same way.

For breeders, unusually warm rearing tanks can skew a batch toward males in sensitive species. Steady temperatures in the first weeks matter most. Results vary between families, so one batch isn’t proof of anything.

Why Some River Fish Are Both Male and Female

Intersex fish have both male and female tissue in their reproductive organs.30PubMed Central. Assessment of Feminization of Male Fish in English Rivers by the Environment Agency of England and Wales In English and European rivers, intersex fish are tied to treated sewage, and they get more common and more severe the more effluent the river holds.30PubMed Central. Assessment of Feminization of Male Fish in English Rivers by the Environment Agency of England and Wales Treated sewage can still contain chemicals that act like estrogen, and fish living downstream absorb them.

In one fish species, river water with 10 nanograms per liter or more of estrogen-like activity went with frequent, severe intersex, while under 0.1 meant little.31PubMed. Modeling the exposure of wild fish to endocrine active chemicals: Potential linkages of total estrogenicity to field-observed intersex In a large US river, fuel- and combustion-related chemicals were most linked to intersex in bass and sunfish.32PubMed. Relation of contaminants to fish intersex in riverine sport fishes

This differs from natural sex change. Clownfish and wrasses change sex fully and can breed afterward, while pollution-driven intersex is a partial, unplanned mix that can weaken breeding. An angler who finds egg tissue in a male bass may be seeing a sign of pollution rather than normal biology.