What Can Skew a PSA Test?

The Prostate-Specific Antigen (PSA) test is a blood analysis used primarily as a screening tool for prostate cancer. It measures a protein produced by both normal and malignant prostate cells; higher concentrations often prompt further investigation. However, the PSA result is not always a direct reflection of cancer, as many non-cancerous factors can influence the protein’s presence in the bloodstream. This phenomenon, known as “skewing,” can lead to misleading results, such as suggesting disease where none exists (false positive) or masking a potential problem (false negative). Understanding these variables is important for accurate interpretation.

Temporary Physical and Procedural Influences

Physical manipulation of the prostate gland can cause a temporary spike in PSA levels by releasing the protein into the bloodstream. The Digital Rectal Exam (DRE), where a physician manually examines the prostate, is one common example. While the elevation is typically minor, some clinicians prefer to draw blood before performing the DRE to avoid this immediate effect. Ejaculation is another frequent cause of temporary elevation due to the mechanical action of the prostate during sexual activity. To ensure an accurate baseline reading, guidelines recommend abstaining from sexual activity for at least 24 to 48 hours before the blood draw.

Vigorous physical activity can also influence PSA concentration, particularly exercises that place direct pressure on the perineum and prostate. Prolonged cycling, for instance, causes temporary elevation due to mechanical trauma and friction against the gland. Patients are often advised to avoid such intense or prolonged activity for up to 48 hours before their scheduled test.

More significant elevations follow certain urological procedures that involve direct intervention or irritation of the prostate tissue. A recent prostate biopsy, which involves taking tissue samples, can dramatically increase PSA levels, requiring a waiting period of four to six weeks before a reliable test. Similarly, the insertion of a urinary catheter or a cystoscopy (a procedure where a thin tube is inserted into the bladder through the urethra) can cause a mechanical release of PSA. Patients are usually advised to wait several weeks after such invasive procedures before retesting to ensure the reading has returned to its natural baseline.

Non-Cancerous Medical Conditions That Elevate Results

Beyond temporary physical actions, certain chronic or acute medical conditions can cause a sustained elevation of the PSA reading without the presence of cancer. These conditions involve physical changes to the prostate gland itself, leading to a higher overall production of the protein. Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (BPH) is the most common condition in older men, involving the non-cancerous enlargement of the prostate.

Since the total volume of the prostate tissue increases in BPH, the total amount of PSA produced naturally rises, causing a sustained high reading proportional to the organ’s size. Physicians often account for this by using PSA density, which divides the measured PSA level by the volume of the prostate, to better assess the result’s significance.

While BPH causes a gradual increase, Prostatitis (inflammation or infection of the prostate) typically causes a rapid and much higher spike in PSA. The inflammatory response damages cellular barriers, allowing a large amount of the protein to leak into the bloodstream. Acute bacterial prostatitis can cause PSA levels to rise dramatically, sometimes exceeding 10 ng/mL, a level often associated with advanced cancer.

This elevation is usually temporary and resolves once the infection is successfully treated with antibiotics. In cases of suspected Prostatitis, physicians often treat the inflammation first and then retest the PSA level several weeks later to determine the true underlying baseline.

Medications That Falsely Lower Readings

While many factors can cause a falsely high reading, certain medications can suppress the body’s natural PSA production, leading to a potential false negative. The most significant class of drugs known to cause this suppression is 5-alpha reductase inhibitors (5-ARIs), which include finasteride (Proscar) and dutasteride (Avodart).

These medications are commonly prescribed to treat BPH or male pattern hair loss. 5-ARIs work by blocking the conversion of testosterone to dihydrotestosterone (DHT), a hormone that stimulates prostate growth and PSA production. This mechanism reduces prostate volume and can lower the measured PSA level by up to 50% after six to twelve months of consistent use.

Because of this suppression effect, the measured PSA level in a patient taking a 5-ARI must often be doubled by the physician for accurate interpretation and comparison to standard screening guidelines. Failing to account for this drug-induced reduction can underestimate a patient’s true risk.

Why Timing and Preparation Are Crucial

The accuracy of a PSA test relies heavily on the patient’s preparation and transparent communication with their healthcare provider. Simple steps taken before the blood draw can mitigate the risk of a misleading result. Patients should inform their doctor about all current medications, including 5-alpha reductase inhibitors, as well as any supplements they are taking.

Disclosing symptoms of a urinary tract infection or recent acute illness is also necessary, as an active infection may prompt a delay in testing. Adhering to recommended waiting periods after physical activity or urological procedures is crucial. This includes avoiding ejaculation and strenuous cycling for the recommended timeframes, and waiting several weeks after invasive procedures like a prostate biopsy. By controlling these variables, the patient assists the provider in obtaining a reading that is as close to the true baseline as possible.