What Eats a Monarch Butterfly: Birds, Mice & More

Monarchs are famous for being poisonous, yet a long list of animals still eats them. Most losses happen early, to small garden insects and parasites that most people never notice. Even adult butterflies have specialist enemies, including birds and mice that have found ways around the poison.

Why Monarchs Are Supposed to Be Safe

Milkweed leaves contain heart toxins. They stop a pump that every animal cell uses to balance salt, which is why they make most animals sick. Monarchs have changes at three spots in that pump that, together, make them largely immune.1PubMed. Stepwise evolution of resistance to toxic cardenolides via genetic substitutions in the Na+/K+ -ATPase of milkweed butterflies (lepidoptera: Danaini)2PubMed Central. Genome editing retraces the evolution of toxin resistance in the monarch butterfly Caterpillars keep the less harmful toxins for themselves, and even those still strongly affect most predators.3PubMed. Testing the selective sequestration hypothesis: Monarch butterflies preferentially sequester plant defences that are less toxic to themselves while maintaining potency to others The protection isn’t free, though. Some milkweed toxins slow caterpillar growth, so the caterpillar pays a price for carrying its defense.4PubMed Central. Cardenolides, toxicity, and the costs of sequestration in the coevolutionary interaction between monarchs and milkweeds5eLife. Cardenolide toxin diversity impacts monarch butterfly growth and sequestration

A bird that swallows the toxins usually isn’t killed. It gets sick, and the vomiting makes the meal unpleasant and memorable.

A naive blue jay that ate a milkweed-raised monarch vomited within about 13 to 17 minutes. It then avoided monarchs and look-alike viceroys.6PubMed Central. Plant poisons in a terrestrial food chain The wings hold very high toxin levels, so a bird often tastes the wing and drops the butterfly.7PubMed. Localization of heart poisons in the monarch butterfly That’s why butterflies with beak-shaped bites in their wings are often survivors of a rejected attack.7PubMed. Localization of heart poisons in the monarch butterfly Hungry or inexperienced birds that tear off the wings and eat the body swallow the most vomit-inducing part.7PubMed. Localization of heart poisons in the monarch butterfly

So a poison defense still lets many monarchs die. A bird learns only after it attacks, and the first monarch may already be dead. The toxin also varies from one butterfly to the next, because a caterpillar can only store what its milkweed supplies. One raised on a weakly toxic species grows into a less protected adult, and two monarchs that look identical can differ a lot in how sickening they are.

It also works only on predators that can feel sick and remember it, which suits birds well. Small insects and spiders that eat eggs or tiny caterpillars don’t learn from one bad meal, so the orange-and-black warning means little to them. Parasitic flies lay their eggs on or in the caterpillar and sidestep the question of taste entirely.

Insects and Spiders That Eat Eggs and Caterpillars

At least 16 kinds of insects and spiders regularly eat monarch eggs, and 11 regularly eat newly hatched caterpillars.8PubMed Central. Predators of monarch butterfly eggs and neonate larvae are more diverse than previously recognised The list includes ants and ladybugs.8PubMed Central. Predators of monarch butterfly eggs and neonate larvae are more diverse than previously recognised Ladybugs are welcomed in gardens for eating aphids, so gardeners are often surprised that they also eat monarch eggs and young caterpillars. The invasive multicolored Asian lady beetle eats both eggs and small caterpillars.9PubMed Central. Eastern North American Monarch Butterfly Conservation Needs and Opportunities: What the Science Tells Us In late-season north Texas, oleander aphids, spiders and fire ants each had small effects on young monarch survival.10Journal of Insect Conservation. Survival of eggs to third instar of late-summer and fall-breeding monarch butterflies (Danaus plexippus) and queen butterflies (Danaus gilippus) in north Texas

Eggs and tiny caterpillars are exposed for simple reasons. An egg can’t move or hide, so any predator wandering across the leaf can eat it. A newly hatched caterpillar is small enough for ants, beetles and spiders to overpower. Young caterpillars have had little time to build up stored toxins, though how much protection they have depends on the milkweed they’ve been eating.

Some invaders hit much harder. Invasive fire ants in Texas have been linked to nearly 100% loss of monarch eggs and caterpillars.9PubMed Central. Eastern North American Monarch Butterfly Conservation Needs and Opportunities: What the Science Tells Us An invasive paper wasp common in cities can turn pollinator gardens into traps for monarch caterpillars.11PubMed Central. Invasive paper wasp turns urban pollinator gardens into ecological traps for monarch butterfly larvae

The European paper wasp is slender, with yellow and black bands and legs that dangle in flight. Its open, umbrella-shaped paper nests often sit under eaves and fences. Because it’s common in cities, urban gardens are especially exposed.

Each predator leaves a different trail. Eggs or small caterpillars that vanish without a trace could have been taken by many different predators, so watching the plants tells you more than the losses alone. Paper wasps carry chewed pieces of caterpillar back to the nest.

To see what’s eating yours, check the milkweed at different times, including early morning and dusk, to catch ants, beetles or wasps at work. Ants climbing the stems or lady beetles resting on the leaves tell you who’s visiting. Marking a few eggs or tiny caterpillars and checking them the next day shows how fast they’re being lost.

Spiders take adults too. Native garden spiders attacked and ate monarchs in about 7 of 9 trials.12PubMed Central. Do Invasive Jorō Spiders (Trichonephila clavata) from Asia Avoid Eating Unpalatable Monarch Butterflies (Danaus plexippus) in North America? The bad taste doesn’t protect a butterfly caught in a web.

Parasitic Flies Inside Caterpillars

The monarch’s main parasites are bristly flies whose young grow inside caterpillars.13Annals of the Entomological Society of America. Tachinid Fly (Diptera: Tachinidae) Parasitoids of Danaus plexippus (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) In a large North American sample, about 13% of wild-collected caterpillars held these flies, and none of those caterpillars survived.14The American Midland Naturalist. Parasitism of Monarch Butterflies (Danaus plexippus) by Lespesia archippivora (Diptera: Tachinidae) Most of the fly larvae came out of the biggest, last-stage caterpillars.15The American Midland Naturalist. Lespesia archippivora (Diptera: Tachinidae) Survival and Sex Ratios within Monarch Butterfly (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) Hosts An introduced parasitic fly can kill a large share of monarch caterpillars.9PubMed Central. Eastern North American Monarch Butterfly Conservation Needs and Opportunities: What the Science Tells Us

The adult fly lays eggs on or near a caterpillar, and the young then grow inside it. The caterpillar keeps eating and growing while the larvae feed within, so it may look normal for a while. Eventually the larvae leave the host, and the caterpillar or chrysalis does not survive.

That timing explains why big caterpillars are the ones that show the flies. Fly larvae need time to grow, so they tend to emerge when the caterpillar is at its largest. A gardener may raise a caterpillar through most of its life before seeing the problem.

A parasitized caterpillar may become sluggish or hang limp, and a caterpillar ready to form a chrysalis may fail and hang limp from its J-shape. White strings may dangle from it as maggots drop to the ground. A chrysalis may darken or show brown spots while still unformed, and small reddish-brown fly pupae may turn up in the rearing container.

If you raise monarchs, remove dead hosts and fly pupae so the flies don’t breed, and clean containers before reusing them.

Birds That Eat Adult Monarchs

Black-backed orioles and black-headed grosbeaks feed freely on monarchs wintering in Mexico.16Nature. Birds can overcome the cardenolide defence of monarch butterflies in Mexico That works because wintering monarchs there are only weakly vomit-inducing.16Nature. Birds can overcome the cardenolide defence of monarch butterflies in Mexico The two birds handle the toxins differently. Orioles taste each butterfly and pick the less toxic parts, so they are selective feeders. Grosbeaks are largely unaffected by the toxin and can eat more of each butterfly.16Nature. Birds can overcome the cardenolide defence of monarch butterflies in Mexico Grosbeaks are unaffected because they evolved changes in the same salt pump at two of the three spots monarchs changed.17Current Biology. What It Takes to Eat a Poisonous Butterfly18PubMed Central. Predators and parasites of cardiac glycoside-sequestering milkweed herbivores converge on toxin resistance

Most backyard birds still leave monarchs alone. Grosbeak-style resistance is rare among songbirds, and summer monarchs on toxic milkweed can be strongly toxic. Most birds learn to avoid the orange-and-black pattern after one bad experience. The Mexican winter is different: the butterflies there are a weak-toxin meal, and birds have a huge, dense food source clustered in the trees, something a summer garden bird never sees.

The toll is large. These two birds killed an average of about 15,000 butterflies a day at one colony.19Evolution. FORAGING DYNAMICS OF BIRD PREDATORS ON OVERWINTERING MONARCH BUTTERFLIES IN MEXICO Over the winter that came to roughly 2 million butterflies, about 9% of the colony.19Evolution. FORAGING DYNAMICS OF BIRD PREDATORS ON OVERWINTERING MONARCH BUTTERFLIES IN MEXICO They took more males, possibly because females carry more toxin.19Evolution. FORAGING DYNAMICS OF BIRD PREDATORS ON OVERWINTERING MONARCH BUTTERFLIES IN MEXICO The birds also seem to feed in cycles, perhaps pausing as toxins build up.19Evolution. FORAGING DYNAMICS OF BIRD PREDATORS ON OVERWINTERING MONARCH BUTTERFLIES IN MEXICO

Mice and the Dangerous Forest Floor

Black-eared mice move into Mexican wintering colonies in large numbers.20PubMed. Behavioral and ecological interactions of foraging mice (Peromyscus melanotis) with overwintering monarch butterflies (Danaus plexippus) in México They eat live and dead monarchs on the ground and in low plants.20PubMed. Behavioral and ecological interactions of foraging mice (Peromyscus melanotis) with overwintering monarch butterflies (Danaus plexippus) in México One mouse attacked about 40 fresh butterflies a night, so mice could kill about 4 to 6% of a colony over a winter.20PubMed. Behavioral and ecological interactions of foraging mice (Peromyscus melanotis) with overwintering monarch butterflies (Danaus plexippus) in México

Mice are small enough to move through low plants and leaf litter, where fallen monarchs lie. They feed at night, when the butterflies are cold and unable to fly. Because they eat dead butterflies as well as live ones, part of the toll falls on monarchs that were already struggling.

Monarchs end up on the ground when wind and heavy rain knock them from their clusters on cool days.21Journey North. What Eats a Monarch Butterfly: Birds, Mice & More Cold monarchs may need hours or days to climb back, and they stay exposed to predators, dew and frost there.21Journey North. What Eats a Monarch Butterfly: Birds, Mice & More

At a colony, grounded monarchs often lie still until sunlight warms them. Watch your step on trails, and don’t pick the butterflies up; let them warm and fly on their own.

How Forests Affect Bird Attacks

Monarchs at a colony’s edge and in thinned forest face much higher risk of being killed.22PubMed. FORAGING DYNAMICS OF BIRD PREDATORS ON OVERWINTERING MONARCH BUTTERFLIES IN MEXICO Areas with fewer trees and less canopy had higher bird-caused deaths.23Biological Conservation. Influence pf forest canopy closure on rates of bird predation on overwintering Monarch butterflies Danaus plexippus L. Logging around wintering sites therefore adds to predation losses.

Dense trees buffer the cluster from wind and rain, so fewer butterflies fall to the ground. The canopy also holds in warmth on cool nights, so butterflies stay clustered and can fly when needed. That lowers losses to mice and to the cold, on top of blocking birds.

Edges and thinned forest are riskier for the opposite reasons. Butterflies at the edge are closer to open air, where birds reach them easily. Thinned forest has fewer branches to hide among, so each cluster is more visible, and an edge monarch faces more wind, so it’s more likely to fall too. Logging near a colony can raise predation even when the colony’s own trees are left standing, because the surrounding canopy matters.

Helping Garden Monarchs Survive

Since city paper wasps target caterpillars, check for wasp nests near your milkweed.11PubMed Central. Invasive paper wasp turns urban pollinator gardens into ecological traps for monarch butterfly larvae Look under eaves, fences and sheds for open, umbrella-shaped paper nests, and do it regularly through the growing season. Watching the milkweed for a few minutes on a warm day shows whether wasps are visiting and carrying off caterpillars. If a nest is close to where people walk, a pest control professional is a safer choice than removing it yourself.

Treat fire ant mounds near milkweed with targeted baits rather than spraying plants. Ants carry the bait into the mound, so the leaves stay uncoated, while spraying the plants would risk the caterpillars you’re trying to protect. This applies mainly where fire ants live, such as the southern states. Avoid pesticides on milkweed generally, since they harm caterpillars too.

When choosing and placing milkweed, spread it in several patches rather than one dense clump. Native milkweeds suit local monarchs best. Mixed flowering plants support the predators of pests without favoring wasps.

Some loss is normal, and only a few eggs in a hundred normally become adults.