What If the Atomic Bomb Was Dropped on Germany?

The atomic bomb was built in a race against Nazi Germany, yet it was never used on Germany. It arrived too late for the European war, which ended in May 1945. The more surprising part is that Japan was chosen as the target long before the bomb existed, so the real story is less about timing than about planning.

Why The Bomb Was Never Ready In Time For Germany

In December 1944, the German Ardennes Offensive pushed American battle casualties to a record 88,000 in one month.1Wikipedia. Atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki – Wikipedia Roosevelt responded by suggesting that atomic bombs be used on Germany as soon as possible.1Wikipedia. Atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki – Wikipedia He was told the first usable weapons were still months away.1Wikipedia. Atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki – Wikipedia

The scarce item was enriched uranium or plutonium, and both came out of enormous plants that had only been running for a limited time by late 1944. A finished design would have had nothing to put inside it.

The two designs show the same limits. The gun-type bomb fired one piece of uranium into another. The implosion-type bomb squeezed a plutonium core with explosives. The implosion design needed a test first, while the gun-type did not. One of each was used on Japan in August 1945.

The production schedule shows how slowly bombs arrived. By late July 1945 the parts of the first uranium bomb had reached Tinian, and the first plutonium bomb parts were about to fly out.2dannen.com. What If the Atomic Bomb Was Dropped on Germany? Planners then expected three or four bombs in September, one of them weaker, at about two-thirds the power of the test bomb.2dannen.com. What If the Atomic Bomb Was Dropped on Germany? They expected at least five in November and seven in December, rising sharply in early 1946.2dannen.com. What If the Atomic Bomb Was Dropped on Germany?

The first atomic test took place in July 1945, more than two months after Germany surrendered. Until then, no commander could have counted on the plutonium bomb for any operation.

Japan Was The Chosen Target Since 1943

On 5 May 1943, two years before Germany’s surrender, the project’s secret steering committee made the first decision about using the bomb.3Institute for Energy and Environmental Research (IEER). What If the Atomic Bomb Was Dropped on Germany? They decided a test drop should land in water in case it was a dud.3Institute for Energy and Environmental Research (IEER). What If the Atomic Bomb Was Dropped on Germany? They also chose Japan over Germany because the Japanese were thought less able to learn from a dud than the Germans.3Institute for Energy and Environmental Research (IEER). What If the Atomic Bomb Was Dropped on Germany? Germany had top physicists who could exploit an unexploded bomb quickly, while Japan’s program was smaller and less able to copy it.

In September 1944, Roosevelt and Churchill met at Roosevelt’s Hyde Park home.4Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. “Always” the target?: While U.S. bomb scientists were racing against Germany, military planners were looking toward the Pacific Their summary said the bomb might be used against the Japanese, with warnings that it would be repeated until they surrendered.4Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. “Always” the target?: While U.S. bomb scientists were racing against Germany, military planners were looking toward the Pacific It did not mention Germany at all.4Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. “Always” the target?: While U.S. bomb scientists were racing against Germany, military planners were looking toward the Pacific Under Truman, the committee advising on the bomb first met after Germany surrendered, so its discussions centred on Japan.4Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. “Always” the target?: While U.S. bomb scientists were racing against Germany, military planners were looking toward the Pacific

Many people assume the bomb was built for Germany and then redirected after May 1945. The motive for building it and the plan for using it were different things. Fear of a German bomb drove the research, while the targeting records point to Japan.

Could A B-29 Have Delivered It Over Europe

Only the B-29 could carry the heavy early bombs over long distances. Yet early plans for B-29 missions in Europe were dropped because of the plane’s development problems and the speed of the Allied advance.5Air Force Magazine. What If the Atomic Bomb Was Dropped on Germany? The B-29 was designed to fly high above enemy defences where the Allies lacked air control.6Simple Flying. Why Was The B-29 Superfortress Not Sent To Europe During WW2? By the time it was ready, the Allies already ruled the skies over most of Western Europe.6Simple Flying. Why Was The B-29 Superfortress Not Sent To Europe During WW2? Smaller B-17s and B-24s did the European bombing more efficiently.6Simple Flying. Why Was The B-29 Superfortress Not Sent To Europe During WW2?

High-altitude bombing also had serious problems. At B-29 altitudes, winds of about 140 mph made formation flying nearly impossible.7The Aviation Geek Club. Here’s why the B-29 could have had a higher loss rate than the B-17 and B-24 over Germany in 1943 Early B-29 bombing accuracy was very poor, defeating the bombsight US doctrine relied on.7The Aviation Geek Club. Here’s why the B-29 could have had a higher loss rate than the B-17 and B-24 over Germany in 1943

The mission itself would have been hard. B-29s would have needed bases in Britain, with runways long enough for a heavily loaded bomber. The plane would then have crossed a long stretch of German-held air. Germany kept night fighters and anti-aircraft guns until late in the war, so the crew could not count on an easy route. A shot-down bomb plane could have put an intact atomic weapon on German soil, which was exactly what planners wanted to avoid.

Tinian worked for Japan because island bases put Japanese cities within B-29 range. By 1945 Japanese air defences were weakened, and the Hiroshima and Nagasaki missions flew with small escorts.

The US Knew Germany Had No Bomb

The Alsos mission was a US atomic spy team that followed Allied troops to find out what German scientists had achieved.8Wikipedia. Alsos Mission By November to December 1944 it concluded there was no German bomb threat and that Germany’s work had stayed experimental.8Wikipedia. Alsos Mission German scientists never built a working reactor and had no large uranium enrichment plants.

The US project was not slowed after this news. It was accelerated.9Institute for Energy and Environmental Research. What If the Atomic Bomb Was Dropped on Germany? The original reason, fear of a German bomb, was gone, but the project had its own momentum: huge spending, thousands of workers, and leaders who wanted a result. Truman, as a senator, had questioned the project’s expense, and stopping would have left a costly weapon unused. The war with Japan was still expected to last into 1946.

Did Racism Shape The Choice Of Japan

Critics of Truman’s decision argue racism played a role and that the bomb would never have been used on Germany.10History. Reasons Against Dropping the Atomic Bomb American propaganda mostly mocked Hitler and the Nazis rather than the German people.10History. Reasons Against Dropping the Atomic Bomb Anti-Japanese propaganda, by contrast, targeted the Japanese as a race, with hatred comparable to Nazi anti-Jewish propaganda.10History. Reasons Against Dropping the Atomic Bomb Propaganda does not by itself prove what decision-makers weighed in a committee room, so historians treat it as one clue.

There is also a practical explanation. The 1943 dud reasoning gave a non-racial motive, since Japan was thought less able to exploit an unexploded bomb. Timing mattered too, because the weapon was ready only after Germany had surrendered. Both explanations can hold at once: a practical rule can be applied by people who also held prejudiced views. The US did firebomb German cities heavily, so Germans were not spared mass bombing.

Would It Have Been Worse Than Dresden

In February 1945, Allied firebombing destroyed much of Dresden. Waves of bombers dropped explosives and fire bombs, creating a firestorm. Some historians and human rights advocates consider Dresden’s bombing on par with the atomic bombings of Japan.11Ellsworth Air Force Base. Firebombing of Dresden The atomic bomb did in one plane and one moment what took hundreds of bombers. Radiation sickness was an extra harm firebombing did not cause, striking survivors days and years afterward.

German cities were dense, and many were already ruins by 1945, so a bomb would have added to damage already done. A shock strike might have pushed some leaders toward surrender, but Hitler’s refusal to quit suggests one bomb might not have ended the fight. Allied troops advancing near a target would also have faced radiation risks that commanders had to plan around.

Surrender worked differently in Japan, where the government still functioned and could decide to surrender. Germany’s surrender came only after Hitler’s death and the fall of Berlin.

How Fallout Travels Over Europe

Winds carry dust long distances. In March 2022, dust from southern Algeria crossed the Mediterranean to Spain and France.12PubMed Central. Radioactive contamination transported to Western Europe with Saharan dust Modern models of a major nuclear plant accident in Western Europe estimate 16 to 24 million people affected.13Archive ouverte UNIGE. Modeling of a Major Accident in Five Nuclear Power Plants From 365 Meteorological Situations in Western Europe and Analysis of the Potential Impacts on Populations, Soils and Affected Countries The number of victims could vary up to 20-fold depending on the weather that day.13Archive ouverte UNIGE. Modeling of a Major Accident in Five Nuclear Power Plants From 365 Meteorological Situations in Western Europe and Analysis of the Potential Impacts on Populations, Soils and Affected Countries

Those models describe power plants, not a 1945 bomb, and a major power plant accident can release far more long-lasting material than one early bomb. They still show how Europe’s crowded map spreads harm across countries. A plume could cross several borders in a day or two, touching neighbouring Allied and neutral countries.

The 1945 bombs exploded in the air, which created less local fallout than a ground burst. A ground burst sucks up soil that carries radioactive material and drops it nearby as heavy fallout, but in an airburst the fireball does not reach the ground, so it does not pull up large amounts of soil. Local fallout from an airburst would have been lighter, though not absent.

What A Bigger Nuclear War In Europe Would Mean

Long-lived radioactive material from a modern nuclear war in Eastern Europe would spread worldwide, with about 40% falling in the Southern Hemisphere.14npj Clean Air. Nuclear Conflict in Eastern Europe: Climate disruption and Radiological fallout A large-scale nuclear war could also bring months of freezing, darkness, and high radiation across the Northern Hemisphere.15PubMed. Long-term biological consequences of nuclear war Smoke from burning cities could block sunlight, and the cold would hit growing seasons. Crops and natural systems could fail for a year or more, leaving survivors facing starvation.15PubMed. Long-term biological consequences of nuclear war

In 1945 only a few bombs existed each month, and each was far weaker than modern warheads. Today thousands exist, many with far more power. A European strike now would not stay local.