What Is a Qubit Physically: Atoms, Electrons & Light

A qubit isn’t one particular object. It is a role that many physical things can play, and inside real quantum computers that role is filled by single atoms, single electrons, supercooled electrical circuits, and individual particles of light.1Wikipedia. Two-state quantum system So asking what a qubit is physically really means asking which natural two-way choice an engineer has learned to control. None of these choices has won yet, because each is good at different things and fragile in different ways.2Discover Quantum Science. A study of qubit modalities in contemporary quantum computing

What Makes Something Usable as a Qubit

Every qubit is an object with two clearly separate states.1Wikipedia. Two-state quantum system An ordinary bit is a switch that is either on or off. A qubit can also sit in a blend of both until it is measured. Real atoms have many energy levels, so engineers pick out just two and ignore the rest.3Physical Review A. Creating qubit states with degenerate two-level systems

That blend is not the same as “we don’t know which.” A qubit’s blend can interfere with itself the way waves do, which ordinary uncertainty never can. Measuring it forces a single answer and destroys the blend.

Whether a candidate object works comes down to a checklist:

Qubits Made From Single Atoms

Single charged atoms, called ions, can be held in place by electric fields in a vacuum.5PubMed. Fast quantum logic gates with trapped-ion qubits Their qubit is two energy levels of the ion’s electrons and nucleus. Linking two ion qubits has been done in under half a millionth of a second, and ions can hold their state about 100 million times longer than such an operation takes.5PubMed. Fast quantum logic gates with trapped-ion qubits A full ion-trap demonstrator machine has even been fitted into a single standard 19-inch equipment rack using calcium ions.6PRX Quantum. Compact Ion-Trap Quantum Computing Demonstrator

In the lab, a camera image shows a row of glowing dots, each one an atom fluorescing under laser light. Lasers and microwaves are aimed at individual dots to flip them or to link qubits so their results are correlated, which is called entanglement.

Flipping an atom qubit works by tuning a laser or microwave pulse to match the energy gap between the two chosen levels. The pulse’s length decides whether the atom ends up in one level, the other, or a blend. Reading it out uses light that only one of the two states responds to, so an atom in that state glows and an atom in the other state stays dark.

Uncharged atoms can be held too, by tightly focused laser beams.7Physical Review A. Coupled dynamics of spin qubits in optical dipole microtraps: Application to the error analysis of a Rydberg-blockade gate To link two of them, one atom is pumped into a swollen high-energy state that blocks its neighbour from doing the same.8Physical Review X. Universal Gate Operations on Nuclear Spin Qubits in an Optical Tweezer Array of Yb 171 Atoms This has linked cesium atoms just 6 thousandths of a millimetre apart.9Quantum Science and Technology. Entanglement of neutral-atom qubits with long ground-Rydberg coherence times The catch is that the atoms’ own jiggling motion blurs the operation, a major remaining hurdle.10Physical Review Applied. Fast, Accurate, and Realizable Two-Qubit Entangling Gates by Quantum Interference in Detuned Rabi Cycles of Rydberg Atoms

Atoms are attractive because every atom of an element is identical, so no two qubits differ through manufacturing flaws. The trade-off is that operations tend to be slower than in circuits.

Qubits Made From Single Electrons

An electron behaves like a tiny magnet that can point up or down in a magnetic field. Trapping one electron in a “quantum dot,” a tiny pocket in a silicon chip, gives a spin qubit.11PubMed Central. The origins of noise in the Zeeman splitting of spin qubits in natural-silicon devices Placing the electron in a steady magnetic field splits its up and down states into two slightly different energies, and that gap defines the qubit. A pulse of oscillating magnetic field or microwaves matched to the gap tips the spin from up toward down, or into a blend of the two.

Reading a silicon spin typically means converting its direction into an electrical signal, since the up and down states can be made to decide whether the electron is able to move onto a neighbouring site. The weak point is noise. Electrical noise in the chip shakes the spin’s energy and erodes the qubit,11PubMed Central. The origins of noise in the Zeeman splitting of spin qubits in natural-silicon devices and moving an electron between neighbouring dots risks losing its state.12Physical Review B. Decoherence of electron spin qubit during transfer between two semiconductor quantum dots at low magnetic fields

Chipmakers like these qubits because they are built with techniques related to ordinary computer chips, and each one is extremely small, so many could fit on one chip. A known drawback is that natural silicon contains atoms whose magnetism adds noise.

Diamond offers a different home for a spin. A missing carbon atom next to a nitrogen atom traps electrons whose spin forms a qubit.13PubMed Central. Robust all-optical single-shot readout of nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond It can be read with lasers alone: one laser excites only one spin state, and a second knocks that electron loose.13PubMed Central. Robust all-optical single-shot readout of nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond The qubit here is a flaw in a crystal, not a pocket engineers draw, and it can work at milder temperatures for some uses. The same diamond defects serve as ultra-sensitive sensors, including gyroscopes,14Physical Review Applied. Optical readout of coherent nuclear spins in diamond coupled to electronic spins in a thermal state and diamond is better established for sensing than for large computers.

Superconducting Circuits as Artificial Atoms

Cooled near absolute zero, certain metals carry current with no resistance. A circuit in such a metal with a thin insulating gap, called a Josephson junction, gets energy levels like an atom’s. Engineers pick the lowest step and the next one up as the qubit’s two states, and avoid pushing the circuit higher. The junction makes the steps unevenly spaced, so a microwave pulse tuned to the first gap does not accidentally kick the circuit into the third level. Microwave pulses control the qubit.15Physical Review Applied. System characterization of dispersive readout in superconducting qubits

Reading it out means pairing the circuit with a small resonator whose pitch shifts depending on the qubit’s state.16Applied Physics Letters. Multiplexed dispersive readout of superconducting phase qubits The resonator is like a tuning fork: a microwave tone bounced off it comes back shifted depending on the qubit. Many resonators can share one wire, each at its own pitch. This readout has been made twice as fast without losing accuracy.17Physical Review Applied. Rapid High-Fidelity Single-Shot Dispersive Readout of Superconducting Qubits

Circuits are made with chip-fabrication tools and can be designed to order, and their operations are very fast. But every circuit differs slightly, unlike identical natural atoms, and they need extreme cooling, covered below.

Qubits Made of Light

Light vibrates in a direction, its polarization, such as horizontal or vertical, and those can be the two states. Alternatively, a photon arriving early or late, in one of two time slots, can be the two states.18Physics Reports. Photonic quantum information with time-bins: Principles and applications One photon can even carry two qubits at once, one in polarization and one in timing.19Physical Review A. Quantum tomography of photon states encoded in polarization and picosecond time bins Beam splitters, which work like partly silvered mirrors, and phase shifters can perform any single-photon operation.20Nature. A scheme for efficient quantum computation with linear optics

A beam splitter puts the single photon into a blend of two possible paths. If the paths are later recombined, the photon’s chance of leaving at each output depends on the relative phase between them, which is how phase shifters steer the result.

Photons fly, while atoms, electrons and circuits stay put. Light barely interacts with its surroundings, so it holds its state well. That same aloofness makes linking two photons hard. So light is the natural messenger between stationary qubits.

Through open air, polarization is favoured because turbulence barely disturbs it.21Optica Quantum. Time-bin encoding quantum key distribution in free-space horizontal links during nighttime and daytime In optical fibre, polarization drifts, so timing slots are used instead, with infrared light that fibre carries with least loss.21Optica Quantum. Time-bin encoding quantum key distribution in free-space horizontal links during nighttime and daytime

Topological Qubits and Other Experimental Ideas

Theory predicts special states, called Majorana zero modes, at the ends of semiconductor wires touching a superconductor.22npj Quantum Information. Majorana zero modes and topological quantum computation A Majorana zero mode is not a new particle sitting in the wire. It is a collective state of the wire’s electrons that appears at the ends. A qubit would be encoded jointly in a well-separated pair of these states, so neither end alone holds the information, and that information would be naturally shielded from local disturbances.23Physical Review B. Majorana zero modes in semiconductor-superconductor hybrid structures: Defining topology in short and disordered nanowires through Majorana splitting

In 2012 a Delft group reported signs of these states in indium antimonide nanowires, later reproduced elsewhere.22npj Quantum Information. Majorana zero modes and topological quantum computation But the reported signal is a peak in electrical current that appears only in a magnetic field, and other effects can mimic that peak. A working topological qubit must show it can store and manipulate information.

Other proposals include magnetic molecules linked by electric fields.24npj Quantum Information. Electrical two-qubit gates within a pair of clock-qubit magnetic molecules Molecules have a history here: the first quantum algorithms in 1998 ran on 2 qubits made from molecules in a liquid, read by NMR.25The Quantum Insider. The Evolution of Quantum Computing Technology

Why Qubits Are So Fragile

Coherence time is how long a qubit holds its state before the surroundings scramble it. In superconducting circuits, tiny flaws in the material that flip between two states are a main culprit.26npj Quantum Information. Decoherence benchmarking of superconducting qubits Even a single such flaw at a metal film’s edge can dominate a qubit’s losses.27PubMed Central. Correlating Decoherence in Transmon Qubits: Low Frequency Noise by Single Fluctuators In one superconducting qubit, frequency wobble capped the hold time at about 0.8 thousandths of a second.26npj Quantum Information. Decoherence benchmarking of superconducting qubits A single trapped rubidium atom held its state up to 3 thousandths of a second, with operations about 95% accurate.28Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics. Implementation of Single-Qubit Quantum Gates Based on a Microwave Transition in a Single Rubidium Atom in an Optical Dipole Trap

Each qubit type has its own enemy. For circuits it is microscopic defects in materials. For electron spins it is electrical and magnetic noise in the chip. Atoms suffer from their own motion and stray laser light. Photons are mostly lost in fibre or air rather than scrambled. Isolation and control pull against each other: a qubit must be touched to be used but left alone to survive.

Why Quantum Computers Are So Cold

Heat is random jostling that scrambles qubits. Solid-state processors therefore sit inside a dilution refrigerator, the gold chandelier seen in photos.29EPJ Quantum Technology. Engineering cryogenic setups for 100-qubit scale superconducting circuit systems Its stacked plates get colder toward the bottom, the chip hangs at the coldest stage, and cables run down through each level. But every control cable carries heat inward, a big problem as qubit counts grow.29EPJ Quantum Technology. Engineering cryogenic setups for 100-qubit scale superconducting circuit systems One approach generates control pulses on a cold chip, fed by thin wires carrying far less heat than coaxial cable.30PubMed Central. A cryogenic on-chip microwave pulse generator for large-scale superconducting quantum computing

Not every qubit needs the big fridge. Superconducting circuits and silicon spins need deep cold. Atoms are cooled by lasers instead, in a room-temperature vacuum. Photons travel at room temperature, though detectors may be cooled.

How Many Physical Qubits Make One Useful Qubit

A logical qubit is an error-protected qubit stored across many physical ones. With ordinary bits, protection can be as simple as storing three copies and taking the majority vote. A qubit’s unknown state cannot be copied exactly, so the information is instead spread across many qubits in a shared pattern. Extra helper qubits then check for signs of an error without reading the stored information itself, which would collapse it.

The overhead is large. A common scheme would need nearly 3,000 physical qubits to protect 12 logical ones, assuming one error per 1,000 operations.31PubMed Central. High-threshold and low-overhead fault-tolerant quantum memory A newer code can do the same with 288 physical qubits.31PubMed Central. High-threshold and low-overhead fault-tolerant quantum memory Neutral-atom designs suggest algorithms with thousands of logical qubits could need under 100,000 physical qubits.32Nature Physics. Constant-Overhead Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computation with Reconfigurable Atom Arrays

A headline qubit count usually means physical qubits. What matters is how many reliable error-protected qubits result, and lower error rates per qubit shrink the overhead dramatically.

Which Kind of Qubit Is Winning

Comparisons find fundamental trade-offs between speed, robustness and complexity.2Discover Quantum Science. A study of qubit modalities in contemporary quantum computing At their theoretical speed limits, neutral atoms and superconducting circuits come out roughly comparable.33Physical Review Research. Comparing planar quantum computing platforms at the quantum speed limit Researchers are still agreeing on common yardsticks even within spin qubits.34Nature Reviews Physics. Review of performance metrics of spin qubits in gated semiconducting nanostructures