What Is the Ashcroft Score for Pulmonary Fibrosis?

The Ashcroft score turns what a pathologist sees in a slice of lung tissue into a single number, from 0 for normal lung to 8 for lung fully replaced by scar.1PubMed Central. Simple method of estimating severity of pulmonary fibrosis on a numerical scale It is a microscope measure of the tissue itself, unlike the scans and breathing tests that guide most patients’ care. You are far more likely to meet it in studies of new fibrosis drugs than in your own medical records.

What the 0 to 8 Scale Means

Pulmonary fibrosis is scar tissue building up in the lungs’ tiny air sacs, which stiffens the lung. The Ashcroft scale was created so that this scarring could be rated as a number and compared with other measures, such as breathing tests.1PubMed Central. Simple method of estimating severity of pulmonary fibrosis on a numerical scale Grades run from 0 to 8, with higher numbers meaning more scarring.1PubMed Central. Simple method of estimating severity of pulmonary fibrosis on a numerical scale The pathologist rates many separate microscope views of the sample and averages them.1PubMed Central. Simple method of estimating severity of pulmonary fibrosis on a numerical scale That means a result can be a decimal, such as 3.4, not just a whole number.

The score can only come from a biopsy, which is a small piece of lung tissue removed, often during surgery, and examined under a microscope. A scan or blood test can’t produce it. Most people with lung fibrosis are diagnosed without a biopsy, so many never have tissue to score.

  • 0: normal lung.
  • 1 to 2: slight thickening of the thin air-sac walls.
  • 3 to 4: clearly thickened walls and some damage to lung structure.
  • 5 to 6: scarring forms larger patches and air spaces are distorted.
  • 7 to 8: severe distortion, large scarred areas, or air spaces filled in by scar.

A sample rarely sits neatly at one grade, and a single slide often contains areas of different grades side by side. A score of 3.4 simply means the typical field fell between grade 3 and grade 4.

A common misreading is to treat the number as a verdict. It describes scarring in the sampled tissue, not your whole lung or your outlook, and a middle score does not translate directly into a stage or life expectancy. Your lung specialist can explain how the number fits with your scan and breathing tests.

How a Pathologist Arrives at the Score

The process starts with preserving the tissue and cutting it into very thin slices. These are colored with stains that make scar tissue stand out.2PubMed Central. Ferroptosis inhibitor alleviates Radiation-induced lung fibrosis (RILF) via down-regulation of TGF-β1 One common stain colors collagen, the main protein in scar, so scarred areas show clearly.2PubMed Central. Ferroptosis inhibitor alleviates Radiation-induced lung fibrosis (RILF) via down-regulation of TGF-β1 The slices are then examined under magnification.

In one approach, ten randomly chosen fields of view are scored from each slice.3PubMed Central. Automated Digital Quantification of Pulmonary Fibrosis in Human Histopathology Specimens Each field gets its own 0 to 8 grade, and the grades are averaged into the final score. Averaging matters because lung scarring is patchy, and one view could be misleadingly mild or severe. It is also why a small biopsy may not reflect the whole lung.

Areas containing large blood vessels and airways are skipped so only the air-sac tissue is rated.3PubMed Central. Automated Digital Quantification of Pulmonary Fibrosis in Human Histopathology Specimens Their walls are thick and rich in collagen, so they look like scar under a stain even in a healthy lung. Including them would inflate the score by mistaking normal structure for disease.

Scorers are often kept unaware of which patient or treatment group a sample came from, to avoid bias.3PubMed Central. Automated Digital Quantification of Pulmonary Fibrosis in Human Histopathology Specimens4PubMed Central. Quantification of Pulmonary Fibrosis in a Bleomycin Mouse Model Using Automated Histological Image Analysis Knowing a sample came from a treated group can unconsciously nudge a grade lower.

Is It Used for Patients or Mainly in Research

Its biggest use is in mouse and rat experiments where lung scarring is caused on purpose with a drug, bleomycin.4PubMed Central. Quantification of Pulmonary Fibrosis in a Bleomycin Mouse Model Using Automated Histological Image Analysis5SMC Laboratories Inc.. Bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis model Bleomycin injures the lung and sets off a scarring response that researchers can produce reliably in a short time. Because the damage begins on a known day, scientists can test a drug given before, during, or after the injury, and using the same dose in every animal gives a consistent starting point for comparing treatments.

Higher doses of bleomycin produce higher Ashcroft scores, which shows the score tracks how much damage is done.4PubMed Central. Quantification of Pulmonary Fibrosis in a Bleomycin Mouse Model Using Automated Histological Image Analysis In mice, scarring and the score peak about three weeks after bleomycin is given.5SMC Laboratories Inc.. Bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis model The score is used in other models too, such as rats with scarring from breathing in silica dust.6PubMed Central. Dynamic assessing silica particle-induced pulmonary fibrosis and associated regulation of long non-coding RNA expression in Wistar rats Animals can’t do routine breathing tests the way people do, so a tissue score gives a direct look at scarring at the end of the study.

Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) is the most common scarring lung disease with no known cause. Researchers have used the score on surgical lung biopsies from people with IPF.7PubMed. IL-4 polymorphisms, HRCT score and lung tissue markers in idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis8PubMed Central. Identification of targetable kinases in idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis It rated higher in human samples with established scarring than in those with minimal scarring.9PubMed Central. Small airways pathology in Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis: A retrospective cohort study Even so, it is a research and pathology tool rather than a standard part of a patient’s diagnosis or treatment plan.

Patient care relies on other tests. High-resolution CT scans show scarring patterns across the whole lung, and breathing tests track lung function over time. Both can be repeated safely, while a biopsy cannot.

How Reliable the Score Is

With the original scale, different scorers agreed only fairly to moderately on the same images.10BioTechniques. Standardized quantification of pulmonary fibrosis in histological samples Even the same scorer looking again often gave a different grade.10BioTechniques. Standardized quantification of pulmonary fibrosis in histological samples A modified Ashcroft scale spelled out exactly what each grade from 0 to 8 must show.10BioTechniques. Standardized quantification of pulmonary fibrosis in histological samples Scorers using it agreed moderately to well with each other and very consistently with themselves.10BioTechniques. Standardized quantification of pulmonary fibrosis in histological samples

“Fair to moderate” agreement means scorers often matched but frequently differed. A scale that changes when the same person looks twice can’t be trusted, so the improvement matters even though it is not perfect.

Disagreement in judging lung scarring tends to be greatest for middle-range cases and smallest for normal or severe lungs.11PubMed Central. Interobserver Variability and Histopathologic Correlation of Lung Ultrasonography in a Bleomycin-Induced Mouse Model of Systemic Sclerosis For a reader, that means a 3 versus a 4 may reflect judgment as much as real difference. Small differences between two reports should not alarm you, and larger gaps or trends say more than one decimal.

Papers and reports may say “Ashcroft” or “modified Ashcroft.” Both use 0 to 8, but the modified version defines grades more strictly, so scores from the two are close but not perfectly interchangeable.

How the Score Relates to Breathing Tests and Scans

Two common breathing tests are FVC, how much air you can blow out, and DLCO (gas transfer), how well oxygen passes from the lungs into the blood. FVC reflects how large and stretchy the lungs are, and scarring that stiffens the lung tends to lower it. The DLCO test reflects how well oxygen crosses the air-sac wall, which thickened or scarred walls can impair. Because they measure different things, one can change while the other holds steady.

In mice, higher Ashcroft scores went along with lower FVC and lower gas transfer.12PubMed Central. Harnessing the translational power of bleomycin model: new insights to guide drug discovery for idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis In people with IPF, a scan-based scarring score tracked lower gas transfer but not lung volume or FVC.13PubMed Central. Pulmonary vascular volume is associated with DLCO and fibrotic score in idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis: an observational study So gas transfer may reflect scarring more closely than lung size does, at least in some patients.

The link between scarring and breathing tests is cleaner in animals because the injury is uniform and the lungs are examined at a set time. People have other conditions, differing disease timelines, and uneven scarring, which blur the connection.

In mice, detailed CT scans of fibrosis matched Ashcroft scores very closely.14PubMed Central. Longitudinal assessment of bleomycin-induced lung fibrosis by Micro-CT correlates with histological evaluation in mice15PubMed Central. In-vivo lung fibrosis staging in a bleomycin-mouse model: a new micro-CT guided densitometric approach But CT cannot tell scarring apart from inflammation, since both make lung tissue look denser.16PubMed Central. Quantitative Assessment of Pulmonary Fibrosis in a Murine Model via a Multimodal Imaging Workflow A treatment can reduce scarring while a scan still looks unchanged because inflammation remains.16PubMed Central. Quantitative Assessment of Pulmonary Fibrosis in a Murine Model via a Multimodal Imaging Workflow Tissue examination is therefore still needed to confirm scarring specifically.16PubMed Central. Quantitative Assessment of Pulmonary Fibrosis in a Murine Model via a Multimodal Imaging Workflow

Scans still dominate patient care because they can be repeated without surgery. Doctors combine scan patterns with symptoms and breathing test trends, and a biopsy is reserved for cases where the diagnosis stays unclear. Your report is more likely to describe scan patterns than an Ashcroft number. Asking how your gas transfer and how much air you can blow out have changed over months is more useful, since trends over time matter more than any single measure.

Why It Appears in News About Fibrosis Drugs

When a drug “lowered the Ashcroft score,” it means that when researchers examined the lung tissue, treated animals had less scarring on average than untreated ones. It says nothing about whether the animals breathed better or lived longer unless those were measured too. The difference also has to be larger than chance, which is why studies compare groups of animals rather than one.

Nintedanib, an approved IPF drug, lowered Ashcroft scores in bleomycin mice.17European Heart Journal. Antifibrotic and anti-inflammatory effects of the selective nonsteroidal MR antagonist finerenone in preclinical pulmonary fibrosis5SMC Laboratories Inc.. Bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis model In rats it shifted scores toward milder scarring whether given in food or by mouth tube.18PubMed Central. A Comparative Assessment of the Antifibrotic Effect of Nintedanib Administered via a Medicated Diet or Oral Gavage in a Rat Model of Bleomycin-Induced Pulmonary Fibrosis Finerenone, a heart and kidney drug, reduced scores as much as nintedanib in mice.17European Heart Journal. Antifibrotic and anti-inflammatory effects of the selective nonsteroidal MR antagonist finerenone in preclinical pulmonary fibrosis But pirfenidone, another approved IPF drug, did not improve scarring in one rat study.19American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine. Potent Antifibrotic Efficacy of Yinfenidone In Vitro and In Vivo Pulmonary Fibrosis Model So a drug’s animal Ashcroft result doesn’t always predict how it helps people.

Timing matters in these studies. Giving a drug early, while scarring is forming, tests prevention, which is easier to show. Giving it after scarring is established tests whether it can slow or reverse damage, which is closer to what patients need. When reading a result, check which approach was used.

Animal scarring also differs from human IPF. Bleomycin scarring is caused on purpose and develops over weeks, while human IPF usually develops slowly over years, so results in animals may not carry over directly. Lower scores in mice are an early step, not proof of benefit in people, and most promising animal results never become approved treatments. For a headline about a new drug, look for human trial results measuring breathing tests and survival.

Newer Ways to Measure Lung Scarring

Computer programs that measure scar on digital slides closely matched pathologists’ Ashcroft scores in mice.4PubMed Central. Quantification of Pulmonary Fibrosis in a Bleomycin Mouse Model Using Automated Histological Image Analysis20PubMed Central. Deep neural network based histological scoring of lung fibrosis and inflammation in the mouse model system Software scans a digital image of the slide and counts the proportion of tissue colored as scar by the stain. It produces a continuous percentage instead of a 0 to 8 grade, and because the rules are fixed, the same slide gives the same answer each time. Computers can also measure whole slides instead of selected views, while pathologists still check results and handle unusual cases.

AI scoring works differently from simple measuring. It is trained on slides already graded by experts, so it learns to imitate how they assign Ashcroft grades, and its output is a grade like the one a pathologist gives. It matched Ashcroft scores well and was about 1.5 times faster.21PubMed Central. Artificial intelligence, machine learning-based automated fibrosis quantification in preclinical models of pulmonary fibrosis Its quality depends on the training slides, so it can fail on tissue unlike what it learned from.

Another approach is chemical. Measuring a component of collagen in lung tissue gives results that track the score.22Mechanisms of lung injury and repair. Quantitation of hydroxyproline in a mouse model of bleomycin-induced lung fibrosis: comparison with histological analysis Most of this is still used in research.