Simulation theory says the world you experience, and your own mind, could be running inside a computer built by a far more advanced civilization. Its most serious version doesn’t claim we are simulated. It claims only that one of three possibilities about the future has to be true.1The Philosophical Quarterly. Are We Living in a Computer Simulation? That makes it a philosophical argument about probability, not a scientific discovery, and nothing so far has shown that we live in a simulation.
The Three Possibilities at the Heart of the Argument
The argument was set out by philosopher Nick Bostrom in 2003. It says at least one of these is true:
- Option one: almost all civilizations at our stage go extinct before reaching technological maturity.2Analysis. The Simulation Argument: some explanations
- Option two: almost all technologically mature civilizations lose interest in running ancestor-simulations, detailed re-creations of their own past.3Analysis. The Simulation Argument: some explanations
- Option three: almost all people with experiences like ours live inside computer simulations.4Analysis. The Simulation Argument: some explanations
“Technological maturity” here means having enough computing power to simulate whole minds and worlds. It is a hypothetical future stage that nobody has reached, and the argument says nothing about when or how it would arrive.
The third option follows if the first two fail. If advanced civilizations survive and do run these simulations, simulated minds would vastly outnumber original ones. Anyone with experiences like yours would then be more likely to be one of the many simulated people than one of the few real ones.
The counting logic is simple: if one real world runs a million simulated copies of its history and you can’t tell which world you’re in, the odds favor being in a copy. The argument also assumes that simulated minds would feel exactly as real as ours. That is why the argument is about beings whose experiences are indistinguishable from ours, not about any program that merely contains characters. A video game with simple figures wouldn’t count, because nothing in it is having experiences like a person’s. The question is whether a simulated being could have a full inner life, with perception, memory and emotion.
Popular versions often say we are “probably” simulated, but the argument doesn’t say that. It only forces a choice among the three options. Someone who thinks civilizations usually go extinct can accept the argument and still reject the simulation. Anyone who rejects the simulation conclusion has to defend a specific claim about the future: that civilizations rarely survive or that they rarely care to simulate.
An Old Question in New Clothes
The simulation idea descends from much older doubts about reality. In the 1600s René Descartes asked whether an evil demon could be deceiving him about everything he perceived.5Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. What Is the Simulation Theory? The Hypothesis Explained The modern brain-in-a-vat thought experiment, a brain fed fake signals by a computer, is usually seen as an updated version of that demon.6Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. What Is the Simulation Theory? The Hypothesis Explained Bostrom’s argument shares an assumption with both: that a mind can carry on unchanged even if the real world that produced it is removed.7Preprints. The Brain in a Vat and the Fourth Proposition: Why the Constitution of the Psychoanalytic Subject Exceeds Computational Sufficiency
The vat story swaps a supernatural deceiver for a technological one, which makes the doubt feel like something engineering could in principle allow. Still, in the vat story there is a real brain and a real world outside, whereas in the simulation idea the mind itself may be software.
Bostrom’s version also asks a different question. Descartes asked whether deception was possible. Bostrom asks how likely simulation is, and his answer rests on predictions about technology rather than a hypothetical demon.
Descartes used the demon to test what he could know with certainty, and he concluded that the fact of his own thinking survived even total deception. His aim was to find solid ground for knowledge, not to claim that a demon existed. Simulation theory borrows the doubt but not the reassurance, since it offers no equivalent certainty to fall back on.
Could Physics Reveal a Simulation
Computer simulations of physics usually chop space into a grid of points to save computing power.8UW News. Do we live in a computer simulation? UW researchers say idea can be tested So some physicists suggest a simulated universe might carry the imprint of such a grid.9UW News. Do we live in a computer simulation? UW researchers say idea can be tested The highest-energy cosmic rays, particles arriving from deep space, might travel along the grid’s diagonals and behave differently in different directions.10UW News. Do we live in a computer simulation? UW researchers say idea can be tested A related idea, digital physics, pictures the universe as a grid of cells updating step by step, which requires space and time to come in tiny separate units.11Wikipedia. Digital physics
Cosmic rays are useful here because they carry far more energy than anything we can produce in accelerators, so they probe the tiniest scales. A grid would favor certain directions, and the test looks for a direction-dependent pattern in measured arrivals.
It does rest on a guess, though: that a simulator would use methods like the grid-based ones we use, technology we have never seen. A more advanced civilization might use methods with no visible grid at all. A grid signal, if found, would be suggestive, but finding none would not settle the question. A missing signal could simply mean a finer grid. That makes the theory hard to rule out, and theories that can’t fail any test are weak scientifically.
Physicist James Gates found that equations in supersymmetry, an unproven theory linking matter and force particles, contain error-correcting codes like those computers use.12The On Being Project. S. James Gates — Uncovering the Codes for Reality Finding computer-like math in physics shows the math is similar, not that a computer is running it. Because supersymmetry itself is unconfirmed, a pattern in its equations rests on a theory that may not describe nature. Other researchers have sketched quantum experiments meant to test the theory, but these remain proposals on paper.13arXiv. On testing the simulation theory
Some physicists argue the universe can’t be computed at all. A 2025 study argued that no computer program can fully describe physical reality, because part of it requires understanding that isn’t step-by-step calculation.14UBC’s Okanagan News. UBCO study debunks the idea that the universe is a computer simulation – UBC’s Okanagan News If that holds, a universe like ours couldn’t be fully simulated.
Strange moments in daily life don’t count as evidence either. Déjà vu and coincidences have ordinary brain and probability explanations, and a capable simulator could hide any errors anyway. Real tests look for precise patterns in physics, not odd experiences.
How Likely Is It, Really
Simulated worlds could run their own simulations, nesting layers inside one another.15PubMed Central. Probability and consequences of living inside a computer simulation But each layer must have less computing power than the one above it.16PubMed Central. Probability and consequences of living inside a computer simulation A simulation has to run on the machine above it, so deep layers would have very little to work with. That is why the number of simulated minds doesn’t grow without limit even if simulations contain more simulations. Under some assumptions about efficiency, simulated beings could make up less than 1% of all conscious beings.17PubMed Central. Probability and consequences of living inside a computer simulation
Physics also caps how much any computer can calculate, with the ultimate limit set by a black hole.18arXiv. Ultimate physical limits to computation Even a civilization of enormous power could not run unlimited simulations.
Simulated minds might also be costly. Simulating a world down to every atom would take enormous power, so simulators might cut corners and simulate only what’s being observed. Whether shortcuts like that could produce genuine experience is an open question.
The numbers are uncertain in any case. Estimates rely on factors nobody can measure, like how much power future civilizations would spend on simulations. Small changes in assumptions swing results from almost certain to very unlikely, so treat any confident percentage you see online with caution.
The Strongest Objections
The theory assumes that a mind could run on any hardware, not just a brain.19Pacific APA symposium / University of Sydney. Simulation Scenarios and Philosophy Philosopher Peter Godfrey-Smith doubts that experience like yours could exist in non-biological form.20Pacific APA symposium / University of Sydney. Simulation Scenarios and Philosophy Modeling brain activity with numbers in memory isn’t the same as having that activity physically happen.21Pacific APA symposium / University of Sydney. Simulation Scenarios and Philosophy His worry is that experience may depend on the electrical and chemical activity of living brains, not just on the pattern of information in them.
This objection also affects the odds. If minds need specific physical processes, simulating one means reproducing those processes, which is far more demanding. Simulated minds become expensive and far fewer,22Pacific APA symposium / University of Sydney. Simulation Scenarios and Philosophy and that weakens the argument’s third option.
A computer simulation of a storm doesn’t make anything wet, so critics ask whether a simulated brain would feel anything. Supporters reply that a storm is a physical thing, while thinking may be information processing that is the same on any hardware. The disagreement turns on what consciousness is, which science has not settled.
A second objection says the theory may defeat itself. The argument is built on science learned from our experience of brains and computers.23The Think Institute. Simulation Theory Debunked But if we’re simulated, that science could be fake, giving us no reason to trust it.24The Think Institute. Simulation Theory Debunked Believing the theory removes the grounds for believing it.25The Think Institute. Simulation Theory Debunked Critics also say a simulator resembles a creator who watches the world, which makes the theory more like faith than science.
Would It Change How You Should Live
Economist Robin Hanson suggested a simulated person might try to be entertaining so the simulation isn’t switched off.26Wikipedia. Simulation hypothesis That rests on guesses about what simulators would want, which nobody can know. It is a speculative thought experiment, not a recommended way to live.
He also warned that believing the theory might make people care less about others or the future.27Wikipedia. Simulation hypothesis Thinking other people are fake could lead someone to treat them badly. But if simulated people feel pain and joy, they matter just as much as anyone. Since you can’t tell whether someone is simulated, treating people as real is the safe and decent default.
Pain, love and the results of your choices would feel the same whether simulated or not. So treating others well and planning ahead still make sense.
The theory raises questions for the simulators too. Some writers argue advanced civilizations would need rules for simulating conscious beings, much like rules for animal research.28Utopia or Dystopia. The Ethics of a Simulated Universe That turns the question back on us: whether we should ever build conscious simulations.
Some people feel anxious or detached after encountering the idea. It can’t be proven, so nothing practical depends on deciding, and philosophers have lived with similar doubts for centuries. If the worry persists or you keep feeling that things around you aren’t real, talk to a doctor.

