What Substances Dissolve in Water and What Doesn’t?

When one substance seems to disappear into another, this process is called dissolving. Solubility describes the maximum amount of a substance (the solute) that can be completely dispersed within a liquid (the solvent). Water is often referred to as the universal solvent because it dissolves more substances than any other liquid. This capacity allows water to carry nutrients, transport waste products, and shape geological processes like mineral erosion. Understanding water’s effectiveness requires a closer look at its fundamental molecular structure.

Water’s Molecular Polarity

A single water molecule (H₂O) consists of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom joined by covalent bonds. The atoms do not arrange themselves in a straight line; instead, they form a bent or V-shape with the oxygen atom at the vertex. This specific geometry is foundational to water’s unique properties as a solvent.

Within these covalent bonds, the oxygen nucleus has a much stronger pull on the shared electrons than the hydrogen nuclei, a characteristic known as high electronegativity. This unequal sharing means electrons spend more time orbiting the oxygen atom, giving it a partial negative charge. Conversely, the hydrogen atoms acquire a partial positive charge.

Because the charges are separated and the molecule is bent, water possesses a strong electric dipole moment. The molecule acts like a tiny magnet, with a distinct positive pole and a distinct negative pole that remain constant. This uneven distribution of charge defines water as a polar molecule.

This strong polarity allows individual water molecules to attract each other through weak electrostatic forces called hydrogen bonds. The partially positive hydrogen atom of one molecule is drawn toward the partially negative oxygen atom of a neighboring molecule. These extensive, interconnected networks of hydrogen bonds give water its high surface tension and allow it to effectively surround and break apart other substances.

The “Like Dissolves Like” Rule

The powerful polarity of the water molecule gives rise to the principle governing solubility: “like dissolves like.” This means that polar solvents, like water, dissolve other polar molecules and substances with full electrical charges, such as ionic compounds. This interaction is driven by the attractive forces between the electrical charges.

When an ionic substance like table salt (NaCl) is placed in water, the charged ions are pulled apart by the strong attraction of the water molecules. The partially negative oxygen ends surround the positive sodium ions (Na⁺), while the partially positive hydrogen ends surround the negative chloride ions (Cl⁻). This organized layer is called a sphere of hydration, which shields the ions from one another. This shielding prevents the ions from recombining into the crystal lattice structure.

Similarly, polar covalent compounds, such as table sugar (sucrose), dissolve readily because they contain many hydroxyl (-OH) groups. These groups allow the sugar molecules to form new hydrogen bonds with the surrounding water molecules. The water molecules then surround the sugar molecule, forming a hydration shell that disperses the solute throughout the solvent.

Conversely, nonpolar substances, which lack significant electrical charges, do not dissolve in water. Substances like oils, fats, and waxes are nonpolar and are repelled by the strong electrostatic fields of the water molecules. Water molecules prefer to bond with each other rather than interact with the nonpolar substance.

This phenomenon is known as the hydrophobic effect, or “water-fearing.” When a nonpolar substance is introduced, water molecules are forced to arrange themselves into a highly ordered, cage-like structure around the nonpolar molecule. This increased order represents an unfavorable state, causing the water to minimize its contact and separate the two liquids.

Even some solids, such as sand (silicon dioxide), do not dissolve because their covalent bonds are too strong for water’s attraction to break. The energy required to separate the silicon and oxygen atoms outweighs the energy released by the formation of new water-solute attractions. The water molecules remain bonded to each other, leaving the solid intact.

Physical Factors That Impact Dissolving

While the chemical nature of the solute and solvent determines if a substance will dissolve, physical factors influence how quickly and how much can dissolve. Increasing the temperature of the solvent increases the solubility of solid solutes. Higher temperatures provide greater kinetic energy to particles, causing them to collide more frequently and with greater force, which helps break apart the solid structure.

This relationship is inverted for gases dissolving in water, such as oxygen or carbon dioxide. As the temperature rises, the gas molecules gain kinetic energy and more easily escape the liquid phase into the atmosphere. This is why warmer water holds less dissolved oxygen, a factor that can impact aquatic ecosystems.

Other physical actions, such as stirring or reducing the size of the solute particles, only affect the rate of dissolution, not the final amount that can dissolve. Stirring brings fresh solvent molecules into contact with the solute’s surface, accelerating the rate at which the substance is carried away. Crushing a solid increases its total surface area, providing more sites for the water molecules to interact, which also speeds up the process.