In 1944, Oswald Avery, Colin MacLeod and Maclyn McCarty published the first strong evidence that genes are made of DNA. It answered a question that had puzzled biology for decades: what material passes inherited traits from one living thing to the next? Most scientists expected the answer to be protein, so the result met resistance for years before it was accepted as a turning point.
The Griffith Puzzle That Started It
The bacterium that causes pneumonia comes in two forms. The rough form lacks a protective outer coat and is harmless. The smooth form is deadly, and it gets its name from the glossy coat that surrounds each cell.1Nature. Transformation of Pneumococcal Types2Nature Education. Isolating Hereditary Material: Frederick Griffith, Oswald Avery, Alfred Hershey, and Martha Chase The coat is what separates the two. It helps the smooth bacterium evade the body’s immune defenses, so white blood cells have trouble engulfing and clearing it. Rough bacteria lack that coat, and the body clears them before they can multiply enough to cause fatal illness. Smooth and rough bacteria also grow as visibly different colonies on a culture dish, so the coat gave researchers a marker they could see by eye.
In 1928, Frederick Griffith found that heating the smooth bacteria killed them and destroyed their ability to cause disease.3Nature Education. Isolating Hereditary Material: Frederick Griffith, Oswald Avery, Alfred Hershey, and Martha Chase Then he injected mice with dead smooth bacteria mixed with living rough bacteria. The mice died, even though neither type caused death alone.4Nature Education. Isolating Hereditary Material: Frederick Griffith, Oswald Avery, Alfred Hershey, and Martha Chase He recovered living bacteria with smooth coats from the hearts of the dead mice.5Nature Education. Isolating Hereditary Material: Frederick Griffith, Oswald Avery, Alfred Hershey, and Martha Chase
That last result was strange. Dead bacteria cannot multiply, so they shouldn’t cause infection, and rough bacteria alone were harmless, so the mixture should have been harmless too. Instead, something from the dead cells had changed the living ones, a process called transformation.6PubMed Central. The Transformation Experiment of Frederick Griffith I: Its Narrowing and Potential for the Creation of Novel Microorganisms The changed bacteria kept their new coat as they multiplied, so the change was inherited, not temporary. That is what turned the mystery into a question about genes. Griffith suspected a chemical from the dead bacteria was responsible but could not identify it.7Nature Education. Isolating Hereditary Material: Frederick Griffith, Oswald Avery, Alfred Hershey, and Martha Chase
How Avery’s Team Tracked Down the Transforming Substance
Avery’s team at the Rockefeller Institute in New York called the unknown substance the transforming principle. Their first job was to move the puzzle out of mice. Colin MacLeod spent 1934 to 1940 developing a rough strain that could be transformed reliably every time.8Rockefeller University Center. DNA: The Transforming Principle and the Birth of Modern Genetics That meant the team could test samples in glass dishes and get consistent answers.
Mouse results are noisy, since an animal might die of something unrelated. In a dish, a change shows up as smooth-looking colonies appearing among rough ones, which can be read directly. That let the team compare many samples at each purification step and see whether activity was kept or lost.
The strain also had a useful property: it could be changed into several different smooth types, depending on which smooth bacteria the extract came from.9Journal of Experimental Medicine. STUDIES ON THE CHEMICAL NATURE OF THE SUBSTANCE INDUCING TRANSFORMATION OF PNEUMOCOCCAL TYPES: INDUCTION OF TRANSFORMATION BY A DESOXYRIBONUCLEIC ACID FRACTION ISOLATED FROM PNEUMOCOCCUS TYPE III So the extract carried specific inherited information, not just a general “make it deadly” signal.
Maclyn McCarty joined in 1941 and worked to purify the substance.10Rockefeller University Center. DNA: The Transforming Principle and the Birth of Modern Genetics The team broke open smooth bacteria with a detergent-like chemical and collected what came out.11The Journal of Experimental Medicine. Studies on the Chemical Nature of the Substance Inducing Transformation of Pneumococcal Types Next they removed proteins with repeated chemical treatment and used an enzyme to digest the sugary coat material that had come along with the extract.12The Journal of Experimental Medicine. Studies on the Chemical Nature of the Substance Inducing Transformation of Pneumococcal Types After each step they checked that the sample could still transform rough bacteria, so they knew the active ingredient wasn’t being thrown away.
Finally, when alcohol was slowly added, the active material came out as long fibrous strands that wound around a stirring rod.13The Journal of Experimental Medicine. Studies on the Chemical Nature of the Substance Inducing Transformation of Pneumococcal Types Seeing strands was a visible clue that the material was a very large molecule. What remained was far purer than the starting extract, though the team did not claim it was perfectly pure. By the end of 1943 they had concluded the purified substance was DNA.14Rockefeller University Center. DNA: The Transforming Principle and the Birth of Modern Genetics
The Tests That Pointed to DNA
The team ran chemical tests first. A standard color test for DNA came out strongly positive.15Journal of Experimental Medicine. Studies on the Chemical Nature of the Substance Inducing Transformation of Pneumococcal Types The balance of nitrogen to phosphorus in the material matched what DNA should contain.16Journal of Experimental Medicine. Studies on the Chemical Nature of the Substance Inducing Transformation of Pneumococcal Types And the substance was made of very large molecules, as DNA is.17Genome.gov. 1944: DNA is \”Transforming Principle\”
These readings show the sample is largely DNA, but they cannot show that DNA is what causes transformation. A small impurity could be present without changing them much. The team needed a test of function, not just composition.
That came from enzymes. An enzyme is a protein that breaks down one specific kind of molecule. Each acts like a key that fits only one lock. Enzymes that destroy protein did not stop transformation.18PubMed Central. Transformation An enzyme that destroys RNA, DNA’s chemical cousin, did not stop it either.19Genome.gov. 1944: DNA is \”Transforming Principle\” But an enzyme that breaks down DNA destroyed the substance’s power to transform.20PubMed Central. Transformation Only the enzyme aimed at DNA mattered, which pointed to DNA as the active ingredient.21Journal of Experimental Medicine. Studies on the Chemical Nature of the Substance Inducing Transformation of Pneumococcal Types
Testing RNA mattered because it is chemically similar to DNA. Because the RNA-destroying enzyme left transformation intact, the active ingredient was DNA specifically, not just any nucleic acid.
The team was careful in how it worded its conclusion, too. The 1944 paper said DNA was the active fraction but stopped short of calling it the gene, since the authors were openly unsure how a seemingly simple molecule could carry specific information.
Why Many Scientists Doubted It
Proteins are built from about 20 different building blocks, while DNA has only four. A popular idea at the time held that DNA was a dull, repeating chain of those four.22PubMed. Dissolution of hypotheses in biochemistry: three case studies Scientists couldn’t see how such a molecule could hold the varied information genes need.23The Embryo Project Encyclopedia. “Studies on the Chemical Nature of the Substance Inducing Transformation of Pneumococcal Types: Induction of Transformation by a Desoxyribonucleic Acid Fraction Isolated from Pneumococcus Type III” (1944) by Oswald Avery, Colin MacLeod and Maclyn McCarty
The doubt was reasonable with what was known. Scientists didn’t yet know that DNA’s order of building blocks could vary endlessly. Meanwhile, proteins were known to do most of the cell’s work, and their variety made them the obvious candidate for carrying genes. Overturning that view required evidence from more than one kind of experiment.
Critics also argued that a trace of undetected protein in the DNA could be doing the work.24PubMed Central. After the Discovery: The Transforming Principle’s Reception by the Scientific Community Alfred Mirsky, a colleague at the same institute, campaigned for years in private and in public for this view.25PubMed Central. After the Discovery: The Transforming Principle’s Reception by the Scientific Community The enzyme results gave a strong reply, since destroying protein left transformation intact.26PubMed Central. Transformation
Still, the worry could not be fully dismissed. No purification is perfect, and the techniques of the 1940s could not prove that zero protein remained. A trace of some unknown protein might be extremely potent, so the enzyme results did not satisfy everyone.
Bacteria made some scientists hesitate as well. They are very simple organisms, and some researchers wondered whether their inheritance worked like that of animals and plants. Transformation looked like a curious trick of a few bacterial species, not obviously a general rule of heredity. The result needed support from other systems before many were willing to change their view.
How Later Experiments Confirmed Avery Was Right
Avery’s paper changed other scientists’ careers. Erwin Chargaff dropped his other research after reading it to study DNA’s chemistry.27Journal of Biological Chemistry. Chargaff’s Rules: the Work of Erwin Chargaff His work began revealing that DNA’s makeup differs between living things. The proportions of DNA’s four building blocks vary from one species to another, which undercut the idea of a uniform, monotonous molecule. That variety is what a genetic material needs, since different species must carry different instructions. His measurements also showed regular matching in the amounts of certain building blocks, a clue that later helped explain the double helix.
In 1952, Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase studied viruses that infect bacteria.28PubMed Central. 1952: Genes are Made of DNA Such a virus is essentially a protein shell holding DNA, which made a clean test of which part carries the instructions. Phosphorus occurs in DNA but not in protein, and sulfur occurs in protein but not in DNA. So they labeled the viruses’ DNA with radioactive phosphorus and their protein with radioactive sulfur.29PubMed Central. 1952: Genes are Made of DNA After infection, the phosphorus went inside the bacteria while the sulfur stayed outside.30PubMed Central. 1952: Genes are Made of DNA Shaking in a blender removed about 80% of the protein label but only about 40% of the DNA label.31The Hershey-Chase Experiments (1952), by Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase. The Hershey-Chase Experiments The bacteria went on to produce new viruses, so only the virus’s DNA needed to enter to make more. That was strong support that genes are DNA.32PubMed Central. 1952: Genes are Made of DNA
Then came the structure. Building on these findings and X-ray work by Rosalind Franklin and Maurice Wilkins, Watson and Crick described DNA’s double helix in 1953.33PubMed. The birth and development of the DNA theory of inheritance: sixty years since the discovery of the structure of DNA The structure showed how four building blocks could store and copy information, which answered the “too simple” objection.
Why Avery Never Won a Nobel Prize
Avery was nominated almost every year from the early 1930s, at first for earlier work on the bacteria’s sugary coats.34Journal of Biological Chemistry. Osvald T. Avery and the Nobel Prize in Medicine A nomination is only a proposal, and the committee often asks outside experts to review whether the work has been proven. In 1946, a reviewer for the committee judged that Avery’s DNA was contaminated with protein.35Journal of Biological Chemistry. Osvald T. Avery and the Nobel Prize in Medicine A 1952 review concluded the final proof was still missing.36Journal of Biological Chemistry. Osvald T. Avery and the Nobel Prize in Medicine By 1954, the same reviewer accepted DNA as the transforming substance yet said the mechanism was unknown.37Journal of Biological Chemistry. Osvald T. Avery and the Nobel Prize in Medicine
Timing worked against Avery. By the time the committee came around, he was elderly and in poor health. He died in 1955, and Nobel Prizes are not given after death. The later prizes for DNA’s structure went to other researchers, whose work came after his.
Historians suggest other reasons. The discovery was ahead of its time.38PubMed. Oswald Avery: the professor, DNA, and the Nobel Prize that eluded him The three authors were physician-scientists rather than recognized chemists or geneticists.39PubMed. Oswald Avery: the professor, DNA, and the Nobel Prize that eluded him And Avery was older and very cautious in presenting his work.40PubMed. Oswald Avery: the professor, DNA, and the Nobel Prize that eluded him
Early popular histories of DNA, like Watson’s account, gave Avery little credit, and his collaborator McCarty felt most histories undervalued Avery’s role. Biology textbooks now treat the experiment as the start of molecular biology, and the 1944 paper is widely regarded as among the most important in 20th-century biology.41PubMed. Oswald Avery: the professor, DNA, and the Nobel Prize that eluded him
Transformation Still Matters Today
What happened in Griffith’s mice is a natural process these bacteria still use. Pneumonia bacteria and close relatives naturally take up DNA from their surroundings.42PubMed. Pneumococcal-Driven Genetic Competence: A Key Driver of Pathobiont Adaptation and Disease Potential When some bacteria die, they release DNA, and living neighbors can pick up fragments of it. The cell can then build that DNA into its own genetic material, the same process Griffith saw. As a result, these bacteria swap genes often and evolve quickly.43PubMed. Pneumococcal-Driven Genetic Competence: A Key Driver of Pathobiont Adaptation and Disease Potential
This DNA uptake also helps them shift from harmless residents of the throat to disease-causing germs.44PubMed. Pneumococcal-Driven Genetic Competence: A Key Driver of Pathobiont Adaptation and Disease Potential A harmless resident can pick up genes that help it cause disease or survive antibiotics, which is one reason bacterial infections can become harder to treat over time. Scientists also use transformation deliberately, to put genes into bacteria in labs.

