Many animals called crabs, including hermit crabs and king crabs, are not true crabs at all.1The Tech Interactive. Is the crab the pinnacle of evolution? These animals belong to a separate branch that arrived at a crab-like look on its own. The crab shape has turned up so many times that biologists treat it as one of evolution’s favorite designs.2PubMed. How to become a crab: Phenotypic constraints on a recurring body plan
Two Branches of One Family Tree
True crabs are the group scientists call Brachyura, which includes spider crabs and Dungeness crabs.3The Tech Interactive. Is the crab the pinnacle of evolution? False crabs belong to a group called Anomura, which includes hermit crabs and king crabs.4The Tech Interactive. Is the crab the pinnacle of evolution? Together the two groups make up a species-rich group of crustaceans found in oceans worldwide.5PubMed Central. Morphological diversity in true and false crabs reveals the plesiomorphy of the megalopa phase
The word “false” is misleading: it is not a sign that the animal is fake or lesser. Many false crabs are eaten and sold as crab, king crab legs being the obvious example. The label sorts animals by ancestry, not by appearance.
The two Latin names are about tails. Brachyura roughly means “short tail” and Anomura roughly means “unlike tail,” so the tail was the feature scientists noticed first. Everyday words like “crab” and “lobster” are not scientific categories. They sort animals by look and by how people use them, so one word like “crab” can cover animals from both branches.
The two groups are close cousins. Genetic and body evidence shows they are each other’s closest relatives.6THE RAFFLES BULLETIN OF ZOOLOGY. Phylogeny of the Decapoda Reptantia: Resolution Using Three Molecular Loci and Morphology7PubMed Central. A comprehensive and integrative reconstruction of evolutionary history for Anomura (Crustacea: Decapoda) Older ideas held that they arose separately from lobster-like ancestors, and that view has been dropped.8THE RAFFLES BULLETIN OF ZOOLOGY. Phylogeny of the Decapoda Reptantia: Resolution Using Three Molecular Loci and Morphology That means the two share a common ancestor no other living group shares. So false crabs are not “less related” to true crabs than a lobster is. They are the nearest relatives true crabs have, cousins that took a different route to the crab shape.
How to Tell Them Apart by Looking
- Legs: true crabs show four pairs of walking legs, while false crabs often show only three, because the fourth pair is tiny and tucked away.9Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Hermit crabs aren’t real crabs. There are hundreds of other crustacean pretenders living right under our noses
- Antennae: true crabs have antennae only between the eyes, while false crabs can have them on the outer side of the eyes.10Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Hermit crabs aren’t real crabs. There are hundreds of other crustacean pretenders living right under our noses
- Shell: a true crab’s shell, the hard lid over its head and body, is broad, flat, usually wider than long, and fused into one plate.11ABC News. Hermit crabs aren’t real crabs. There are hundreds of other crustacean pretenders living right under our noses
- Segments: some false crabs have a shell that still looks segmented, a bit like paving stones.12ABC News. Hermit crabs aren’t real crabs. There are hundreds of other crustacean pretenders living right under our noses
- Tail: true crabs fold a flat tail fully under the body with no fan, so a visible tail fan points to a false crab, though many false crabs lack one.13ABC News. Hermit crabs aren’t real crabs. There are hundreds of other crustacean pretenders living right under our noses14Marine Conservation Society. Crab facts to give you claws for thought
To check a crab on a beach or in a tank, count the legs behind the claws first, since that is the easiest test. Then look at the front for long antennae outside the eyes, and watch the animal from behind or below for any tail fan.
Leg counting works because both groups descend from ancestors with five pairs of thoracic legs, and the first pair became the claws. That leaves four pairs for walking in a true crab. In many false crabs the last pair is shrunken and held inside the shell cavity, so it is easy to miss.
Antennae are the long feelers on the front of the head, and both groups have a short pair and a long pair. In true crabs the long pair is tiny and sits between the eyes, so most true crabs look as if they have no long feelers at all. Porcelain crabs and hermit crabs have obvious long ones, so a crab with prominent whip-like antennae is a good false-crab candidate.
Shell shape helps too. A true crab’s fused plate makes the top of the body look like one smooth lid, and it gives the wide, rounded or boxy outline most people picture as “crab.” A false crab’s shell can show grooves that mark off sections, giving it a patchwork look. Still, some false crabs are flat and wide too, so treat shell shape as one clue among several.
The tail clue works because both groups descend from tailed ancestors. True crabs reduced the tail to a flat flap held tight under the body, while many false crabs keep fan pieces at the tail tip.
Don’t count the claws as walking legs. A true crab that has lost a leg can look like a false crab, so use more than one feature.
Familiar False Crabs You May Know
King crabs descend from hermit crab ancestors and sit within the family tree of a common hermit crab group.15PubMed. Evolution of king crabs from hermit crab ancestors Leaving the borrowed shell and becoming fully crab-shaped took roughly 13 to 25 million years.16PubMed. Evolution of king crabs from hermit crab ancestors Some living species look halfway between hermit crabs and king crabs.17Contributions to Zoology. The anatomy of the king crab Hapalogaster mertensii Brandt, 1850 (Anomura: Paguroidea: Hapalogastridae) – new insights into the evolutionary transformation of hermit crabs into king crabs Their bodies are part shell-dweller and part king crab, and their tails are partly hardened and no longer fit well inside a shell, a sign they have started to leave the borrowed home. They give scientists a living model of what king crab ancestors may have looked like.
Red king crab legs are very long and spiny, unlike the smoother legs of snow crab. The tail is folded but lopsided, a leftover from ancestors that coiled their tails into spiral shells, and that helps explain why the animal looks a little different from snow crab or Dungeness.
Porcelain crabs have compact, flat bodies suited to hiding under rocks.18PubMed. Porcelain crab They show three pairs of walking legs and have long antennae outside the eyes.19PubMed. Porcelain crab They feed by combing plankton from the water with feathery mouthparts.20PubMed. Porcelain crab In slow water they sweep actively, and in fast currents they hold out their fans and let the water bring food.21Marine Ecology Progress Series. Costs and gains of porcelain crab suspension feeding in different flow conditions The name comes from their fragility: a porcelain crab can drop a claw if grabbed and grow it back later. They look like true crabs at first glance until you count the legs.
Mole crabs dig backward into sand using their rear legs and tail parts, which act like oars.22Journal of Experimental Biology. The Mechanism of Burrowing of the Mole Crab, Emerita They are the small diggers in wet sand at the water’s edge, burying themselves quickly as each wave goes out, and unlike most true crabs they have no big claws. The coconut crab is the largest land-living arthropod, reaching about 4 kg and more than half a meter across.23PubMed. Insect-like olfactory adaptations in the terrestrial giant robber crab Apart from its larval stage at sea, it lives fully on land and will drown if kept underwater.24PubMed. Insect-like olfactory adaptations in the terrestrial giant robber crab
Why So Many Animals Become Crab-Shaped
The crab-like body, wide and flat with the tail bent under, evolved separately at least five times in ten-legged crustaceans.25PubMed. How to become a crab: Phenotypic constraints on a recurring body plan This is called carcinization, a name from 1916.26Biological Journal of the Linnean Society. One hundred years of carcinization – the evolution of the crab-like habitus in Anomura (Arthropoda: Crustacea) The word comes from the Greek for crab and describes a body that becomes shorter, broader and flat, with the tail folded forward beneath it.
Unrelated animals can end up alike because they face similar challenges, as with wings in birds and bats. That is why shape alone cannot reveal which branch a crab-like animal belongs to.
The shape pays off. A crab shape lowers the center of gravity, which makes fast sideways escape possible.27Wikipedia. Carcinisation Legs set to the sides keep the run steady, and fleeing sideways lets a crab keep its claws toward a threat. The tucked tail protects the soft organs inside, and a shell over the back plus a folded tail leaves fewer soft parts to bite.28Wikipedia. Carcinisation A compact frame also fits into rock and coral crevices.29Wikipedia. Carcinisation
The change can go in reverse. Some crab-shaped lineages lost the shape again.30Scientific American. Why Do Animals Keep Evolving into Crabs? This happened multiple times in both true and false crabs.31Wikipedia. Carcinisation
How Old These Lineages Are
Ten-legged crustaceans first split into separate lines in the Late Ordovician, about 450 million years ago.32PubMed Central. A phylogenomic framework, evolutionary timeline and genomic resources for comparative studies of decapod crustaceans Most living lineages branched in the age of early dinosaurs, after a mass extinction.33PubMed Central. A phylogenomic framework, evolutionary timeline and genomic resources for comparative studies of decapod crustaceans
More than 3,000 fossil true crab species are known from the Jurassic onward, so true crabs were well established by the time of the dinosaurs.34bioRxiv / Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory. Fossil calibrations for molecular analyses and divergence time estimation for true crabs (Decapoda: Brachyura) Their earliest origins are still unclear.35bioRxiv / Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory. Fossil calibrations for molecular analyses and divergence time estimation for true crabs (Decapoda: Brachyura) Crab fossils are mostly pieces of hard shell, the parts that survive burial best, and gaps in the record are why scientists also use genetic evidence to estimate when lineages split.
The crab look in false crabs is much younger than the ancient family. Some king crab lineages split off roughly 32 to 50 million years ago, during a period of global cooling.36PubMed Central. Comparative phylomitogenomic analyses provide insights into adaptation and carcinization in Anomura

