Where Does the Seaweed We Eat Come From?

Nearly all the seaweed on our plates is grown on ocean farms rather than gathered from wild shores.1PubMed Central. The Evolution Road of Seaweed Aquaculture: Cultivation Technologies and the Industry 4.0 That farming is concentrated in a handful of Asian countries, so most seaweed in Western stores is an import.2FAO. Quarterly Seaweed Analysis Where a seaweed grows, and which kind it is, also affects what ends up in it, from iodine to traces of metals.3Journal of Food and Drug Analysis. Analysis of iodine content in seaweed by GC-ECD and estimation of iodine intake

The Countries That Grow Most of the World’s Seaweed

Asia produced about 99.5% of the world’s seaweed by volume in 2021, about 35 million tonnes.2FAO. Quarterly Seaweed Analysis China, Indonesia, the Philippines, both Koreas, Japan and Malaysia together account for roughly 98% of farmed seaweed.4Seaweed Insights. Global Production Overview

Here is how the producers rank in 2022:

Figures differ slightly between sources because they cover different years and some count all algae, but China first and Indonesia second holds either way.

Only about 3.5% of seaweed comes from wild beds. About 96.5% is farmed in water.1PubMed Central. The Evolution Road of Seaweed Aquaculture: Cultivation Technologies and the Industry 4.0

A seaweed farm is mostly ropes or nets anchored in shallow coastal water, with young seaweed attached to them. The plants grow on the sea’s own nutrients, with no feed or fertilizer. Growers usually harvest from boats, cutting or pulling the grown fronds, and many farms are small family plots rather than big companies.

Not all of it ends up on a plate, though. Much tropical farmed seaweed is red seaweed grown for thickeners used in processed foods, not eaten as a vegetable.6Phycologia. Phyconomy: the extensive cultivation of seaweeds, their sustainability and economic value, with particular reference to important lessons to be learned and transferred from the practice of eucheumatoid farming

A country’s share tells you where seaweed is grown, not where it is eaten, because much of what China and Indonesia grow is processed or exported before it reaches shops. Shares are also by weight of the harvested seaweed, which is mostly water, so the share of dried food seaweed on shelves can look quite different.

Where Nori, Wakame and Kombu Come From

Nori is the thin dark sheet wrapped around sushi. It comes from a group of red seaweeds, with about 20 of 150 species growing around Japan.7seaweed.ie. Nori Cultivation Japan farms two of them, and one forms most of the crop.7seaweed.ie. Nori Cultivation Japanese breeders developed fast-growing nori varieties through careful selection.7seaweed.ie. Nori Cultivation That breeding shapes what you buy. Farmers choose varieties for growth speed, colour, tenderness and tolerance of water conditions, so the seaweed in a package is a selected crop, not a random harvest.

Wakame, the soft green seaweed in miso soup and seaweed salad, is grown along most of Japan’s coast, and also in China and Korea.8Kurakon Foods Corporation. Major Production Area of Wakame – Seaweed Encyclopedia Japan’s Sanriku coast is prized for wakame thanks to nutrient-rich currents.8Kurakon Foods Corporation. Major Production Area of Wakame – Seaweed Encyclopedia Wakame from the fast-current Naruto strait is known for a thick, crisp texture.8Kurakon Foods Corporation. Major Production Area of Wakame – Seaweed Encyclopedia Kombu, a thick kelp used to flavour broths like dashi, is the third of the group. Kombu, nori and wakame are the key farmed crops of Korea, Japan and China.9Phycologia / Taylor & Francis Online. Seaweed breeding programs and progress in eastern Asian countries

On a package, sushi nori and snack sheets are usually labelled from Korea, China or Japan. Japanese regional names like Sanriku or Naruto usually mark a product sold as premium. A “product of” line may name where it was packed, not where it grew.

How Seaweed Gets From the Sea to Your Kitchen

Harvested nori is cleaned, minced and blended into a mixture.10Yamamotoyama U.S.A.. HOW NORI SEAWEED IS MADE The mixture is poured into molds, sponge-pressed and fan-dried into sheets.10Yamamotoyama U.S.A.. HOW NORI SEAWEED IS MADE The thin layer set on the mold is what gives sushi nori its even, paper-like thickness. Drying uses carefully controlled warm air, because the sheet must be dry enough to stay crisp but not so dry or hot that it turns brittle or loses colour. Many sheets are then lightly toasted, often by the maker, which brings out flavour and a deeper green-black colour.

Cut wakame becomes sellable only after blanching, salting, draining, sorting and chilling.11Earth Lab. The recovery of seaweed aquaculture: rebuilding Sanriku wakame and kombu, its workforce and blue carbon This first processing often happens right on the pier.12Bord Iascaigh Mhara. Technical visit to Japan’s Seaweed Industry – specifically focussed on kelp production and large scale processing techniques After salting and two days of pressing, it lasts about 60 days, or up to 3 years frozen.12Bord Iascaigh Mhara. Technical visit to Japan’s Seaweed Industry – specifically focussed on kelp production and large scale processing techniques

That is why seaweed is almost always sold dried or salted. Fresh seaweed spoils quickly once out of the water, and removing water lets it ship worldwide.

Salted wakame needs a good rinse to remove the excess salt. Dried wakame only needs a few minutes of soaking before it goes into a salad.

The Smaller Share That Is Picked Wild

Dulse, a red seaweed, has been eaten for centuries.13Journal of Applied Phycology. Concise review of the red macroalga dulse, Palmaria palmata (L.) Weber & Mohr It is still hand-picked on the shore in Western Europe, Canada and Maine.13Journal of Applied Phycology. Concise review of the red macroalga dulse, Palmaria palmata (L.) Weber & Mohr

It stays small-scale because wild seaweed grows on rocky shores and must be cut by hand at low tide, which limits how much one picker can gather. Weather, tides and season make supply uneven compared with a farm tended on a schedule. Beds can also be overharvested, so local rules and traditions often limit how and when it is gathered. Labels on these products often say “hand-harvested” and name the coast, and they usually cost more than imported farmed seaweed.

If you want to gather your own, pick only from clean water away from sewage outlets and harbours, and check local rules, since some areas restrict harvesting. Cut fronds rather than pulling the base so the plant regrows.

Is Imported Seaweed Safe to Eat

Seaweed absorbs metals from seawater, including arsenic, lead and cadmium.14Journal of Agriculture and Food Research. Heavy metals in seaweed: Implications for health benefits, risks, and safety regulations Levels vary hugely between products, with inorganic arsenic, the harmful form of arsenic, ranging from nearly none to over 100 mg per kg.15PubMed. Total arsenic, inorganic arsenic, lead and cadmium contents in edible seaweed sold in Spain Hijiki, a brown seaweed, is the standout. Every hijiki sample sold in Spain exceeded the harmful-arsenic limit some countries set.15PubMed. Total arsenic, inorganic arsenic, lead and cadmium contents in edible seaweed sold in Spain Eating as little as 1.7 g of hijiki a day could reach the World Health Organization’s weekly tolerable intake for a 68 kg adult.16PubMed. Heavy metal, total arsenic, and inorganic arsenic contents of algae food products Some products also exceeded cadmium limits used abroad.15PubMed. Total arsenic, inorganic arsenic, lead and cadmium contents in edible seaweed sold in Spain Spain, like many places, had no specific legal limits for these contaminants in seaweed.16PubMed. Heavy metal, total arsenic, and inorganic arsenic contents of algae food products

Soaking and boiling hijiki can reduce some of the arsenic, but not reliably enough to make regular eating a good idea. So the usual advice is to avoid it or eat it only rarely rather than try to prepare it safely.

Kombu carries far more iodine than other seaweeds, averaging about 2,500 mg per kg dried.3Journal of Food and Drug Analysis. Analysis of iodine content in seaweed by GC-ECD and estimation of iodine intake Wakame averaged about 140 and nori about 37 mg per kg.3Journal of Food and Drug Analysis. Analysis of iodine content in seaweed by GC-ECD and estimation of iodine intake One kombu sample reached over 4,900 mg per kg.3Journal of Food and Drug Analysis. Analysis of iodine content in seaweed by GC-ECD and estimation of iodine intake A small piece of kombu can therefore supply far more iodine than an adult needs in a day, and too much iodine over time can upset thyroid function. Farms near industry or cities can pick up more metals.17Future Foods. Seaweed Traceability of Geographic Origin and Detection of Species-Mislabeling: Trends, Methods, Challenges, and Implications for the EU Industry

Microplastics can stick to the surface of seaweed.18Malaysian Journal of Analytical Sciences. Microplastics contamination on seaweed surface at rocky shore habitat in Port Dickson beaches Washing removed about 94.5% of plastic particles stuck to a European seaweed.19Journal of Applied Phycology. Sorption of fluorescent polystyrene microplastic particles to edible seaweed Fucus vesiculosus

Nori snacks are lower in iodine than kombu and generally lower risk, though eating large amounts still adds up. Hijiki and kombu are the two to limit. Many health agencies advise avoiding hijiki. Use kombu sparingly for flavour, and take extra care in pregnancy or with thyroid conditions.

Seaweed Farms in North America and Europe

Most US seaweed farming is kelp grown on ocean farms on the east and west coasts.20Aquaculture. Identifying challenges of the US domestic seaweed aquaculture industry The US sugar kelp industry is growing in both raw harvest and new products.21Marine Policy. Geographical considerations for capturing value in the U.S. sugar kelp (Saccharina latissima) industry Farming technology has recently spread from Asia to the Americas and Europe.1PubMed Central. The Evolution Road of Seaweed Aquaculture: Cultivation Technologies and the Industry 4.0

Sugar kelp grows in cold water through winter. Farmers hang lines of young kelp in the sea in autumn and let it grow over the cold months with no feed, then harvest in spring, a different calendar from the warm-water seaweeds in Asia. With the harvest in a short window, growers often freeze or dry it to sell through the rest of the year.

European growers use land tanks, nearshore and offshore farms, and farms combined with shellfish.22Sustainability Science and Technology. Life cycle assessment of seaweed cultivation and harvesting in Europe and the United States But EU production remains limited, so Europe relies on Asian imports.17Future Foods. Seaweed Traceability of Geographic Origin and Detection of Species-Mislabeling: Trends, Methods, Challenges, and Implications for the EU Industry

To find local seaweed, look for kelp noodles, flakes and frozen kelp from Maine or Alaska. Coastal farmers’ markets sometimes sell fresh kelp.

Is Seaweed Farming Good for the Ocean

Seaweed soaks up nitrogen and carbon as it grows.23Journal of the World Aquaculture Society. Evaluation of nutrient bioextraction by seaweed and shellfish aquaculture in Korea It uses nitrogen as a nutrient, so a farm in water with extra nitrogen turns that excess into plant tissue. The nitrogen leaves the sea only if the seaweed is harvested and taken away, rather than left to decay. Korea’s main farmed seaweeds and shellfish removed nitrogen equal to about 8.6% of what its wastewater plants discharge.23Journal of the World Aquaculture Society. Evaluation of nutrient bioextraction by seaweed and shellfish aquaculture in Korea Farmed red seaweed removed nitrogen from polluted New York City estuary waters in one season.24Aquaculture. Field scale evaluation of seaweed aquaculture as a nutrient bioextraction strategy in Long Island Sound and the Bronx River Estuary In Denmark, seaweed farming could meet local nitrogen goals in some river basins.25PubMed. Bioextraction potential of seaweed in Denmark – An instrument for circular nutrient management A seaweed farm can take up some excess nitrogen but does not stop pollution at its source.

Seaweed farms can also provide shelter and food for fish and small animals.26Reviews in Aquaculture. Habitat value of bivalve shellfish and seaweed aquaculture for fish and invertebrates: Pathways, synthesis and next steps In tropical waters, natural seaweed beds held twice as many young fish as seagrass.27Marine and Freshwater Research. Tropical seaweed beds as important habitats for juvenile fish Longer-term farms that harvest only part of each plant offer more lasting habitat.28Journal of Applied Phycology. Seaweed cultivation and its impacts on biodiversity: a study from the Faroe Islands

How Warming Seas Could Change Where Seaweed Grows

Kelp is a cold-water plant, and warmer water slows its growth and can make its tissue break down. In northern China, ordinary farmed kelp starts to decay in late March to early April as water warms.29Global Seafood Alliance. Could triploid kelp cultivars expand seaweed farming in the face of climate change? – Responsible Seafood Advocate Heat tends to arrive at the end of the season, so a farm can lose part of its crop just before harvest. New heat-resistant varieties keep growing into mid-April.29Global Seafood Alliance. Could triploid kelp cultivars expand seaweed farming in the face of climate change? – Responsible Seafood Advocate

Breeders can now predict heat tolerance in sugar kelp at its earliest life stage, speeding breeding.30Journal of Applied Phycology. Predicting heat tolerance in sugar kelp juvenile sporophytes via gametophyte heat stress testing Selective breeding is also being used to future-proof giant kelp against warming.31PubMed Central. Heat stress analysis suggests a genetic basis for tolerance in Macrocystis pyrifera across developmental stages For shoppers, longer growing seasons help keep supply and prices steady, though some farming may shift to cooler waters over time.