Which Sumac Is Edible and Which Is Poisonous

The sumac you can eat is the one most people notice: bright red berries held upright at the tips of the branches. Poison sumac carries pale berries and is rarely seen at all. In North America, berry color is a quick first clue: the edible sumacs have red berries, while poison sumac and relatives such as poison ivy have whitish ones.1Colorado Arts and Sciences Magazine. Smooth sumac has edible berries and poisonous but medicinal leaves Poison sumac isn’t really a sumac. It has been moved into the same plant group as poison ivy and poison oak.2PubMed. Recognizing the Toxicodendrons (poison ivy, poison oak, and poison sumac) So the real question is less which sumac is safe than how to tell a harmless spice plant from a poison-ivy relative.

How to Tell Edible Sumac From Poison Sumac

Start with the berries. Edible sumac berries are red and packed tightly into upright, cone-shaped clusters.3The Spruce. Poison Sumac vs. Staghorn Sumac: The Major Differences These clusters grow only at the ends of branches.4Backyard Forager. Sumac Berries: a Necessary Spice Poison sumac has small green or white berries,5The Chopping Block. Sumac Foraging and Preparation which ripen to an off-white color in fall.3The Spruce. Poison Sumac vs. Staghorn Sumac: The Major Differences

Leaves and twigs confirm it. Both plants have leaves made of many leaflets, so leaf shape alone won’t settle it.3The Spruce. Poison Sumac vs. Staghorn Sumac: The Major Differences Staghorn sumac leaflets have toothed edges, while poison sumac leaflets are smooth-edged.3The Spruce. Poison Sumac vs. Staghorn Sumac: The Major Differences Poison sumac twigs and bark are smooth, while staghorn twigs are covered in tiny hairs.3The Spruce. Poison Sumac vs. Staghorn Sumac: The Major Differences Fuzzy, velvety branches point to staghorn, which is named for their likeness to a young deer’s antler.6Farmers’ Almanac. Wild Edibles: Yes, There Is a Sumac Berry You Can Eat

Location is a strong clue too. Poison sumac grows only in wetlands such as open swamps, marshes, and fens,7Penn State Extension. Spectacular Sumacs so most people rarely walk into its habitat. A sumac on a dry roadside or field edge is very unlikely to be poison sumac.

In the field, look first for red upright cones at the branch tips. Then run a finger along a leaflet edge to feel for teeth, and notice whether the ground underfoot is soggy or dry. Touch only the twig, and only once the other signs agree that you have staghorn. If any sign disagrees, leave the plant alone.

Poison ivy is a different story. It usually has three leaflets per leaf, unlike most sumacs’ many, and its whitish berries fit the color rule. It grows almost anywhere, including dry ground, so the wet-only rule applies just to poison sumac.

Seasons change how a sumac looks. The berry check is most reliable once the cones have colored. Edible sumac leaves turn bright red in fall, and the dried red cones often stay on bare branches into winter, so a leafless shrub can still be identified by those upright clusters. Poison sumac also turns showy orange-red in fall, so autumn color alone proves nothing.

Which Sumacs Are Edible

The edible sumacs in the U.S. include smooth, staghorn, and three-leaved sumac, all with red, sour berries.4Backyard Forager. Sumac Berries: a Necessary Spice Smooth sumac is the most widespread in North America, found in every state except Alaska and Hawaii.6Farmers’ Almanac. Wild Edibles: Yes, There Is a Sumac Berry You Can Eat Staghorn grows as a large shrub or small tree up to 30 feet tall, with leaves that turn brilliant red in fall.6Farmers’ Almanac. Wild Edibles: Yes, There Is a Sumac Berry You Can Eat The berries of smooth and staghorn can be used interchangeably in the kitchen.6Farmers’ Almanac. Wild Edibles: Yes, There Is a Sumac Berry You Can Eat The sumac sold as spice comes mainly from a Middle Eastern species and is a key ingredient in za’atar.4Backyard Forager. Sumac Berries: a Necessary Spice

Smooth and staghorn look alike from a distance, so only a close look at the twigs separates them. Smooth sumac has hairless twigs and branches, while staghorn’s young twigs are covered in velvety fuzz. Smooth twigs are not a warning sign, though. Poison sumac twigs are smooth too, so confirm a smooth sumac by its toothed leaflets, red upright cones and dry habitat rather than by twigs alone.

Edible sumac usually grows in sunny, open, disturbed ground, such as roadsides, field edges, fence lines, railway banks and abandoned lots. It spreads by underground runners and often forms dense colonies, so one patch you notice may be many stems from a single root system.

What Poison Sumac Does to You

Poison sumac contains urushiol, an oily sap that causes an itchy skin rash in many people.8Scientific American. What Do Cashews, Mangoes and Poison Ivy Have in Common? Rashes from poison ivy, oak, and sumac are among the most common skin conditions in the U.S.9PubMed Central. Toxicodendron Contact Dermatitis: A Case Report and Brief Review.

After contact, wash the skin with soap and cool water as soon as you can. The rash-causing oil binds to skin, and the sooner it is washed off, the less of it can take hold. Wash the clothes, gloves and tools that touched the plant, and bathe a pet whose fur brushed it, because the oil can linger on surfaces and cause a rash later. The rash usually appears a day or two after contact, and the fluid inside the blisters does not spread it. New patches usually mean more oil on skin or objects, or areas that reacted more slowly. See a doctor if the rash is on the face or near the eyes, is widespread, or keeps getting worse.

Smoke is the more serious danger. Burning these plants makes smoke that irritates the lungs, and breathing it can cause severe allergic breathing problems.10Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Protecting Yourself from Poisonous Plants Never burn brush that might include poison sumac.

Trouble breathing after exposure to smoke from burning brush needs urgent medical care, even if the person felt fine at first. Swelling of the face, lips or throat is an emergency that calls for emergency services right away.

Plants That Look Like Edible Sumac

Tree of heaven is often confused with sumac because both have long leaves of many leaflets and grow along roadsides and railroads.11bplant.org. Tree of Heaven (Ailanthus altissima) vs Staghorn Sumac (Rhus typhina): Identification Both also spread into colonies from one root system.11bplant.org. Tree of Heaven (Ailanthus altissima) vs Staghorn Sumac (Rhus typhina): Identification The differences are clear up close. Tree of heaven leaflets are smooth-edged with one or two small bumps at the base, while staghorn leaflets are toothed.12Penn State Extension. Tree of Heaven: Native Look-alikes Tree of heaven has orange to brown clusters that hang down, not red upright cones.13Buckeye Yard and Garden Line. Tree of Heaven vs. Sumac: How can you tell the difference? Snapped twigs differ as well: staghorn has firm white pith, and tree of heaven has brown, spongy pith.13Buckeye Yard and Garden Line. Tree of Heaven vs. Sumac: How can you tell the difference?

Tree of heaven’s seed clusters are not a sumac spice, and its smooth leaflets could be mistaken for poison sumac’s. Checking for red upright cones avoids both mix-ups. Smooth leaflets alone can’t separate tree of heaven from poison sumac, so the fruit and the setting have to settle it.

Make the checks in order. Look at the fruit first, since it is visible without touching the plant: hanging orange-brown seed clusters versus red cones standing upright. Then check the leaflet edges, and last, snap a small twig to see the pith.

When and How to Harvest Sumac Berries

Sumac berries ripen between late July and early October, depending on how far north you are.6Farmers’ Almanac. Wild Edibles: Yes, There Is a Sumac Berry You Can Eat Color deepens before flavor develops, so red alone doesn’t mean ready, and a cluster that looks perfect may not yet taste sour.4Backyard Forager. Sumac Berries: a Necessary Spice The sour coating dissolves in water, so heavy rain rinses it off.6Farmers’ Almanac. Wild Edibles: Yes, There Is a Sumac Berry You Can Eat Harvest after several dry days, before a downpour.6Farmers’ Almanac. Wild Edibles: Yes, There Is a Sumac Berry You Can Eat Hot, dry weather makes the berries more sour, so a dry spell can give an especially tart harvest.4Backyard Forager. Sumac Berries: a Necessary Spice

Tasting is the real test. Lick a berry lightly: if it tastes sour the cluster is good, and if it tastes dusty the rain stripped it.6Farmers’ Almanac. Wild Edibles: Yes, There Is a Sumac Berry You Can Eat If the first cluster you try is bland, test other plants, since coating loss can vary with how sheltered a cluster was. Cut whole clusters with pruners into a paper bag.6Farmers’ Almanac. Wild Edibles: Yes, There Is a Sumac Berry You Can Eat They often hold ants, ladybugs, or caterpillars, so brush them off.6Farmers’ Almanac. Wild Edibles: Yes, There Is a Sumac Berry You Can Eat Use them within a couple of days, or dry the clusters whole for spice.6Farmers’ Almanac. Wild Edibles: Yes, There Is a Sumac Berry You Can Eat

Leave some for wildlife. Sumac fruit stays on the plant through winter and feeds many birds, including bluebirds, robins and turkeys, when other food is scarce. Take a few clusters per plant rather than stripping a stand.

How to Use Edible Sumac

For sumac-ade, break the clusters up a little and cover them with about two quarts of room-temperature water. Let them soak until the water turns pink.4Backyard Forager. Sumac Berries: a Necessary Spice Cold soaking tastes better than boiling, because boiling water can pull bitter tannins from the seeds.4Backyard Forager. Sumac Berries: a Necessary Spice Strain the liquid well through cheesecloth or a coffee filter to remove seeds and staghorn’s fine hairs.4Backyard Forager. Sumac Berries: a Necessary Spice The drink tastes similar to hibiscus or rosehip tea, bright and tart,5The Chopping Block. Sumac Foraging and Preparation and many people sweeten it to taste.

For spice, dry the clusters first, then pulse the berries briefly in a blender to separate the red outer layer from the hard seeds.14Serious Eats. Foraged Flavor: All About Sumac Rub the result through a medium-fine strainer, keeping the red powder and discarding the seeds.14Serious Eats. Foraged Flavor: All About Sumac Toast the powder briefly at 300°F for 5 to 8 minutes until aromatic.5The Chopping Block. Sumac Foraging and Preparation Stored airtight, it keeps about a year.5The Chopping Block. Sumac Foraging and Preparation Use it like lemon on grilled meat, rice, chickpeas, eggplant, or salads.5The Chopping Block. Sumac Foraging and Preparation

You can also buy it. Store-bought sumac is usually the Middle Eastern species. A red dye not allowed in food has been found in some sumac spice,15PubMed. Discovery and structural elucidation of the illegal azo dye Basic Red 46 in sumac spice so buy from reputable sellers and be wary of unusually bright powder.

Sumac and Nut or Mango Allergies

Sumac belongs to the cashew family, along with mango, pistachio, cashew and poison ivy.8Scientific American. What Do Cashews, Mangoes and Poison Ivy Have in Common? These plants contain urushiol-type compounds to varying degrees,8Scientific American. What Do Cashews, Mangoes and Poison Ivy Have in Common? which is the link behind cross-reactions: a person allergic to one may react to another. People allergic to cashews or pistachios should check with a doctor before eating sumac, because a reaction to food can be more serious than a skin rash.

Someone who reacts strongly to poison ivy may want to try a tiny amount first rather than a full serving. Stop eating at any itching of the lips or mouth, since that can be an early sign of a reaction.