Who Made Sign Language? Origins and History

No one person invented sign language. Deaf people create sign languages themselves whenever enough of them come together, which is why the world has many separate sign languages rather than one. Famous educators often get the credit because they built schools around signs that deaf people were already using, and the Abbé de l’Épée in 18th-century Paris is the best known.1deafhistory.eu. 1712 – 1789: Abbé Charles Michel de l’Epée

How New Sign Languages Are Born

In the late 1970s and 1980s, deaf children in Nicaragua who had no shared language were brought together in new schools. Over about 25 years they created a brand-new sign language.2PubMed. Children creating core properties of language: evidence from an emerging sign language in Nicaragua The first children broke events into basic pieces and put them in order, using grammar rules that are not found in the gestures of hearing Nicaraguans.2PubMed. Children creating core properties of language: evidence from an emerging sign language in Nicaragua Each new group of young learners added more structure, turning early gesture into a full language.2PubMed. Children creating core properties of language: evidence from an emerging sign language in Nicaragua

The earliest signing looked a lot like pantomime, with loose gesture-like signs that acted events out. Later children used fixed signs and consistent placement in space to show who did what to whom.

Linguists count the later signing as a true language, not just better gesturing. It combines a limited set of parts into endless new messages, which loose pantomime cannot do. Later signers could also talk about the past, about things not present, and about other people’s actions, so the language was no longer tied to the here and now.

The new grammar came mainly from children aged 10 and younger.3PubMed. Children creating language: how Nicaraguan sign language acquired a spatial grammar New rules spread to other children and to later classes, but adults of the same era did not pick them up.4Cognitive Development. Intergenerational influence and ontogenetic development in the emergence of spatial grammar in Nicaraguan Sign Language So each class of children inherits a richer language than the one before and pushes it further.4Cognitive Development. Intergenerational influence and ontogenetic development in the emergence of spatial grammar in Nicaraguan Sign Language

The schools did not teach any of this. What they supplied was the crowd: many deaf children together every day, the one ingredient a scattered population lacks. Because the children met daily for years, their signs were repeated and shared, and the habits that caught on became the group’s norms. Their teachers were not fluent in any sign language, so the grammar could not have been handed down from them. Researchers could watch it arise precisely because no sign language existed in the schools to copy.

Sign Systems a Single Deaf Person Creates

A deaf child raised among hearing people who don’t sign often creates a homesign, a personal gesture system used with family. In one studied homesigner, a side-to-side headshake marked “no” and a hand flip marked questions.5PubMed Central. Negation, questions, and structure building in a homesign system The headshake usually came at the start of a sentence and the flip at the end, a consistent grammar pattern.5PubMed Central. Negation, questions, and structure building in a homesign system

These gestures differ from the ones hearing people make. Hearing relatives gesture while they talk, but their gestures are loose and lean on the speech beside them. A homesigner’s gestures have to carry the whole message, so they become more regular and get strung together in a consistent order. Often the child produces more structure than the family does, so the child is not simply copying the people around them.

Even so, a family gesture system is not a full sign language. It is shared with only a few relatives, so its vocabulary stays small, and no other fluent users exist to refine it, unlike the Nicaraguan school community. When homesigners meet each other, though, their systems can become the seeds of a shared language.

For parents, a child’s home gestures are a sign of a mind ready for language. Giving the child an established sign language early provides a full language to grow with. Late exposure to any language can leave lasting gaps, which is the reason early access matters.

Signing Before Deaf Schools

In the fifth century BC, Plato’s Socrates said that people without voices would use hands, head, and body to communicate, as deaf people did then.6Wikipedia. History of sign language Aristotle, however, claimed that deaf people were also unable to speak or reason in language.7History. The history of sign language Roman law barred people born deaf from signing a will, assuming they understood nothing.7History. The history of sign language Deaf communities likely signed throughout history, but few records survive because their languages weren’t valued.

Monks in Europe developed sign systems to keep vows of silence, written down by the 7th to 8th centuries AD.8PubMed. Sign language: its history and contribution to the understanding of the biological nature of language Sign use spread through French and central European monasteries from the 11th and 12th centuries.9Ciências Socialmente Aplicáveis e Humanidades: Saberes, Práticas e Horizontes de Investigação V. A HISTORICAL VIEW OF SIGNS AND SIGN LANGUAGES AS A POTENTIAL FOR SECRET COMMUNICATION IN TWO WORLDS: IN OTTOMAN COURTS AND CATHOLIC RELIGIOUS ORDERS Around 1600, monastic signs helped teachers communicate with deaf children of Spanish nobility, which became a core of later deaf education.9Ciências Socialmente Aplicáveis e Humanidades: Saberes, Práticas e Horizontes de Investigação V. A HISTORICAL VIEW OF SIGNS AND SIGN LANGUAGES AS A POTENTIAL FOR SECRET COMMUNICATION IN TWO WORLDS: IN OTTOMAN COURTS AND CATHOLIC RELIGIOUS ORDERS

Monastic signs were a limited code for hearing monks, not a native language. They mostly covered daily needs like food and prayer. Their value was as a bridge that let hearing teachers start communicating with deaf students.

In the 1600s the Ottoman court in Istanbul employed about 40 deaf servants, chosen because of their signing.10JSTOR Daily. The Secret Sign Language of the Ottoman Court Speaking, even whispering, before the sultan was considered improper, so many courtiers learned the signs.10JSTOR Daily. The Secret Sign Language of the Ottoman Court Little is directly known about that court language today.11Wikipedia. Ottoman Sign Language

The Abbé de l’Épée and the Birth of ASL

In 1755 Abbé Charles-Michel de l’Épée founded the first free school for deaf people, in Paris.1deafhistory.eu. 1712 – 1789: Abbé Charles Michel de l’Epée He first learned the signs deaf Parisians already used, then built his teaching system on them.1deafhistory.eu. 1712 – 1789: Abbé Charles Michel de l’Epée He also added signs to follow spoken French word order.1deafhistory.eu. 1712 – 1789: Abbé Charles Michel de l’Epée Unlike earlier teachers, he opened his classrooms to the public and trained foreign teachers, so his students and trainees started deaf schools across Europe and beyond.12Wikipedia. Charles-Michel de l’Épée

In his classroom, he taught groups of deaf students using signs, writing, and pictures, then linked those signs to written French. Visitors could watch deaf students reading, writing, and answering questions, which challenged the old belief that deaf people could not be educated.

His added grammar signs did not last. They were built to mirror French word endings and word order, so they followed hearing French rather than deaf people’s own grammar. Deaf signers tended to drop such additions and keep the natural signing that suited them.

In 1817 Thomas Hopkins Gallaudet and the deaf French teacher Laurent Clerc opened the first permanent US deaf school, in Hartford, Connecticut. Students arrived with their own home and community signs, since the US had no standard sign language.13Human Development Institute. Who Made Sign Language? Origins and History Those signs mixed with Clerc’s French Sign Language, and ASL was born.13Human Development Institute. Who Made Sign Language? Origins and History ASL and French Sign Language are still related, like cousins.

One community feeding into ASL was Martha’s Vineyard, where deafness was so common that many families had deaf and hearing siblings.14Wikipedia. Martha’s Vineyard Sign Language Because deafness was inherited recessively, almost any family could have deaf children. Hearing islanders signed too, so deaf people were not isolated.

Why Sign Language Was Banned in Schools

In 1880 the International Congress on the Education of the Deaf in Milan voted that speech should take preference over signs.15European Review of History: Revue europeenne d’histoire. Oralism: A Sign of the Times? The Contest for Deaf Communication in Education Provision in Late Nineteenth-century Scotland Schools moved to oralism, teaching deaf children only through speech and lip-reading.16World Federation of the Deaf. UNESCO & 1880 Milan Congress | Deaf History Recognised In practice, sign language was effectively banned in classrooms.15European Review of History: Revue europeenne d’histoire. Oralism: A Sign of the Times? The Contest for Deaf Communication in Education Provision in Late Nineteenth-century Scotland Deaf people’s own groups say generations faced language deprivation and exclusion, effects still felt today.16World Federation of the Deaf. UNESCO & 1880 Milan Congress | Deaf History Recognised

Most delegates in Milan were hearing educators, and deaf teachers were mostly absent from the decision. The vote did not itself outlaw signing everywhere, but it gave authority to those who wanted speech only. Schools in many countries then changed their methods over the following years.

Many hearing educators believed speech was needed to fit into society, and sign language was wrongly seen as primitive gesture. Deaf teachers were largely pushed out of schools.

In the classroom, children were often punished for signing, sometimes with their hands restrained. Many spent years on speech drills instead of reading and school subjects. Deaf children kept signing secretly in dorms, which helped the languages survive.

Proof That Sign Languages Are Real Languages

At Gallaudet University, William Stokoe became the first linguist to study ASL as a language, starting in the 1960s.17Wikipedia. William Stokoe He showed that each sign is built from parts such as handshape, location, and movement, much as words are built from sounds.17Wikipedia. William Stokoe Handshape is the form the hand takes, location is where the sign is made, and movement is how the hand travels. Two signs can differ in only one part, much as two spoken words can differ in one sound, and that small change alters the meaning. Brain imaging later found that British Sign Language in deaf signers and spoken English in hearing people activate the same main language areas of the brain.18PubMed. Neural systems underlying British Sign Language and audio-visual English processing in native users

A common myth is that ASL is English on the hands. ASL has its own grammar and word order, separate from English, and facial expressions carry grammar, such as marking questions.

This research changed things. Recognition as a language helped bring signing back into deaf schools, and colleges began accepting ASL as a foreign language. Deaf communities gained confidence in pushing for official recognition.

Is Sign Language the Same Everywhere

Researchers have identified at least six sign language families plus many languages unrelated to any other.19Boostlingo. 6 Sign Language Families | Where They’re Used | Boostlingo Some likeness between sign languages comes from contact, and some from a common ancestor, as with ASL and French Sign Language.20Sign Language Studies. Historical Linguistics and the Case for Sign Language Families In Middle Eastern comparisons, two neighboring sign languages shared about 58% of vocabulary.21PubMed Central. Sign language geography But a village sign language close to Jordan shared only 24% with Jordanian Sign Language, and ASL about 18%.21PubMed Central. Sign language geography Borders and spoken languages don’t predict how similar sign languages are.

That is why ASL and British Sign Language differ despite the shared English. BSL developed separately in Britain’s own deaf communities, and an ASL signer and a BSL signer can struggle to understand each other. ASL is closer to French Sign Language because of Clerc.

There is no universal sign language because wherever deaf communities grew separately, they built their own languages, just as hearing groups did. Deaf travelers often communicate across languages more easily than hearing people, because they draw on pictorial signs and shared habits. An international signing used at conferences exists, but it is a loose contact system and not a full native language.

Not all signing comes from deaf communities. Plains Indian Sign Language was used across much of North America as a shared language between nations.22Sign Language Studies. Hand Talk: Sign Language among American Indian Nations It served trade, diplomacy, and storytelling among people with different spoken languages.23Wikipedia. Plains Indian Sign Language It is still used in ceremonies and by deaf people in daily life.23Wikipedia. Plains Indian Sign Language

Sign Languages Still Taking Shape Today

Protactile, a touch-based language, emerged among DeafBlind people in Seattle in 2007.24PubMed Central. From Contact to Conversation: Protactile Language, Modality, and Community Many were born deaf, learned ASL as children, then slowly lost sight, as in Usher syndrome.25PubMed. Protactile Before Protactile, their conversations, even with each other, almost always went through interpreters.24PubMed Central. From Contact to Conversation: Protactile Language, Modality, and Community Tactile ASL, in which ASL signs are felt through the hands, evolved in the DeafBlind community and differs from simple touch signals.26Tactile Communications, LLC. Tactile Communications, LLC

Protactile is built for touch from the start rather than adapting visual signs. Listeners give constant touch feedback, like nodding in speech, and the language lets DeafBlind people talk directly without relying on interpreters. It grew when DeafBlind people met each other and built a shared way of communicating, not through a single inventor.

Baby sign is a different thing. Parents teach some signs to hearing babies before they talk. It borrows a few signs but isn’t a full language, and it differs from a deaf child learning ASL as a native language.

Recognition is the current frontier. The UN human rights office urges countries to make national sign languages official.27OHCHR. The importance of sign languages to foster human rights: an OHCHR perspective Recognition helps deaf people take part in public decisions and get services like interpreted media.27OHCHR. The importance of sign languages to foster human rights: an OHCHR perspective