The warning isn’t really about sushi as a food. It is about raw fish, which can carry germs that cooking would normally kill. Sushi made with cooked fish or vegetables is generally fine during pregnancy.1Expecting Health. The Pregnant Woman’s Guide to Eating Seafood Pregnancy itself shifts the immune system in a way that makes some of these germs easier to catch and lets them reach the baby. The advice is not to give up fish, though, because cooked fish feeds the baby’s growing brain.
The Germs in Raw Fish That Matter Most in Pregnancy
Some fish can carry Listeria, Vibrio and Salmonella, bacteria that cause food poisoning in pregnant women.2Journal of African Contemporary Research. IMPACT OF MICROBIAL FLORA 0N SEAFOOD CONSUMPTION BY PREGNANT WOMAN Listeria is a bacterium found in soil, water and animals, and it can end up on seafood. Eating raw fish or shellfish, including oysters, also raises the risk of Vibrio, norovirus and other food-borne infections for anyone.3Canadian Family Physician. Food safety during pregnancy
Salmonella, Vibrio and norovirus usually cause a short bout of vomiting or diarrhea that the mother can recover from, though dehydration still matters in pregnancy. With Listeria, the main danger is the infection reaching the baby, not how sick the mother feels.
Most bacteria slow down or stop growing in the cold, but Listeria keeps multiplying in the fridge. Cold-smoked salmon, such as lox, is never cooked, and it can support Listeria growth even when refrigerated.4PubMed. Shelf-life boundaries of Listeria monocytogenes in cold smoked salmon during refrigerated storage and temperature abuse A sealed contaminated food, the bacteria can cross the gut lining and enter the bloodstream.5Food Microbiology. Growth of Listeria monocytogenes, Aeromonas hydrophila and Yersinia enterocolitica on cold-smoked salmon under refrigeration and mild temperature abuse, chilled, in-date pack of smoked salmon is not proof that it is safe in pregnancy. Because the fish is never cooked, nothing kills the bacteria before you eat it, and contaminated fish usually looks, smells and tastes normal.
The foods that count as raw or cold-smoked seafood include sashimi, nigiri and rolls made with raw tuna, salmon or yellowtail. Refrigerated lox and smoked salmon on bagels count too, even though they seem cooked. Raw oysters and clams carry their own germs, so they belong on the list. Smoked fish that has been canned, is shelf-stable, or has been cooked into a hot dish is a different matter.
Handling at the counter adds risk on top of the fish itself. Sushi made with bare hands had more contamination, and staph bacteria turned up on about 1 in 5 samples.6PubMed. Microbial Quality and Safety of Sushi Prepared with Gloved or Bare Hands: Food Handlers’ Impact on Retail Food Hygiene and Safety Handlers who washed their hands and put on fresh gloves left almost no target bacteria.6PubMed. Microbial Quality and Safety of Sushi Prepared with Gloved or Bare Hands: Food Handlers’ Impact on Retail Food Hygiene and Safety Hands dried on reused dishcloths carried food-poisoning bacteria far more often than hands dried with paper towels.6PubMed. Microbial Quality and Safety of Sushi Prepared with Gloved or Bare Hands: Food Handlers’ Impact on Retail Food Hygiene and Safety
Why Pregnancy Makes These Infections More Dangerous
During pregnancy, the body tones down one arm of the immune system so that it doesn’t attack the baby.7PubMed Central. Emerging Infections and Pregnancy The immune system has one branch that handles germs floating outside cells and another that hunts germs hiding inside them. Rising pregnancy hormones turn down the immune cells that fight infections from the inside.8PubMed. Foodborne infections during pregnancy That second branch is the one at risk of treating the baby’s foreign tissue as a threat, so it is the one that gets quieted.
Pregnant women are not immune-suppressed across the board, and the change mainly affects germs that hide inside cells.7PubMed Central. Emerging Infections and Pregnancy Many food-borne germs, including Listeria, live inside cells and are normally kept in check by this arm of the immune system.8PubMed. Foodborne infections during pregnancy
The result is a much higher risk. Pregnant women are about 18 times more likely than other people to get a Listeria infection.9PubMed. Listeriosis during pregnancy After you swallow9PubMed. Listeriosis during pregnancy From the blood they reach the placenta, which is meant to shield the baby but can become infected itself. From the placenta, the infection can spread to the baby.9PubMed. Listeriosis during pregnancy
Infection can lead to miscarriage, early labor, infection of the womb, meningitis in the newborn, or death.10PubMed. Pregnancy Complicated by Listeria Monocytogenes: A Case Report and Review of the Literature When the baby is infected, 25 to 35% die, depending on how far along the pregnancy is.9PubMed. Listeriosis during pregnancy
The mother and baby can be affected very differently. The mother may only feel mildly unwell or have flu-like symptoms while the baby is seriously harmed at the same time. That mismatch is why waiting to see how bad you feel is not a safe strategy. The higher susceptibility lasts through the whole pregnancy, so there is no “safe” trimester for raw fish.
Why Freezing and Good Restaurants Don’t Solve It
Freezing is used to make sushi fish safer because it kills parasitic worms in the flesh.11NPR. Why Freezing Didn’t Keep Sushi Tuna Safe From Salmonella But freezing only slows Salmonella down, and only cooking or pasteurizing kills it.11NPR. Why Freezing Didn’t Keep Sushi Tuna Safe From Salmonella Frozen sushi fish has still caused Salmonella outbreaks. Bacteria in the fish can survive the freezer and begin growing again as the fish thaws. A label saying the fish was previously frozen speaks to worms only and says nothing about Listeria or Salmonella.
“Sushi-grade” is a marketing term about quality and freshness, not a sign that the fish is free of germs. Even a careful, reputable restaurant cannot remove bacteria from fish it serves raw. Bacteria can come from the water, the processing plant or the transport, long before the fish reaches the kitchen. A spotless kitchen, with fresh gloves and hand washing, lowers the chance of adding new contamination but cannot take out what is already on the fish.
Cooking does work. Cook seafood until it is opaque and flakes easily. Use smoked salmon only when it is cooked into a hot dish such as a bake or pasta. Searing the outside, as with tataki, leaves the center raw, so it doesn’t count.
Sushi You Can Still Eat While Pregnant
Sushi is generally safe in pregnancy as long as it is made with vegetables or cooked seafood.1Expecting Health. The Pregnant Woman’s Guide to Eating Seafood Pregnant women are advised to skip raw or undercooked seafood, refrigerated smoked seafood, and sushi made with raw seafood.2Journal of African Contemporary Research. IMPACT OF MICROBIAL FLORA 0N SEAFOOD CONSUMPTION BY PREGNANT WOMAN So ask how each roll is made instead of going by its name.
Common safe orders include California rolls made with cooked crab or imitation crab, shrimp tempura and other fried rolls, and eel (unagi), which is served cooked. Cucumber, avocado, egg (tamago) and sweet potato rolls are fine too.
Some menu items are traps. Spicy tuna and salmon rolls are raw inside. Philadelphia rolls usually contain cold-smoked salmon. Fish roe and raw scallop are often raw. A cooked roll prepared on the same board as raw fish can pick up its germs, so ask the staff.
If you make sushi at home, use cooked shrimp, canned salmon, or cooked crab as fillings. Keep prepared rolls in the fridge and eat them the same day. Wash your hands, use clean surfaces, and dry your hands with paper towels.
Mercury Is a Separate Issue From Raw Fish
Germs are a raw-fish problem, and cooking kills them. Mercury is a fish-type problem, and cooking does nothing to it. Raw tuna sushi therefore carries both risks at once.
Large predatory fish build up mercury, and the bigger the fish, the more it tends to carry.12PubMed Central. Mercury Contamination in Fish and Its Effects on the Health of Pregnant Women and Their Fetuses, and Guidance for Fish Consumption—A Narrative Review Pregnant women are advised to avoid shark, swordfish, tilefish and king mackerel.13PubMed Central. Health benefits and health risks of contaminated fish consumption: Current research outputs, research approaches, and perspectives Tuna, such as bonito, was the fish most closely tied to mercury in newborns’ cord blood in Japan.14PubMed. Association between prenatal mercury exposure and pediatric neurodevelopment: The Japan environment and children’s study
Mercury from fish crosses the placenta,15MotherToBaby. Methylmercury in Fish so it can reach higher levels in the baby’s blood than in the mother’s.15MotherToBaby. Methylmercury in Fish Pollutants in fish such as PCBs and dioxins have been linked to harm to the developing baby, including low birth weight.13PubMed Central. Health benefits and health risks of contaminated fish consumption: Current research outputs, research approaches, and perspectives
The evidence also has reassuring parts. In more than 3,000 Japanese children, mercury levels at birth were not linked to their later development.14PubMed. Association between prenatal mercury exposure and pediatric neurodevelopment: The Japan environment and children’s study Most seafood contains more selenium than mercury, which counters mercury’s harm, though some sharks and other top predators are exceptions.16Fishes. Selenium, Mercury, and Health Benefit Values of Pelagic Ocean Fish of the Central North Pacific
To lower your intake, choose different fish or eat less of the high-mercury kinds. Salmon, shrimp, cod, sardines and canned light tuna are lower-mercury choices. Limit albacore tuna, avoid the large predators listed above, and eat a variety of fish so no one source adds up.
Why You Shouldn’t Cut Out Fish Entirely
Getting enough omega-3 fats in pregnancy is important for the baby’s brain, and too little is linked to lower developmental scores.17PubMed Central. Omega-3 Fatty Acids and Pregnancy DHA, an omega-3 fat found in fish, is needed to build brain connections before birth and through age 2.18PubMed Central. Maternal Docosahexaenoic Acid Status during Pregnancy and Its Impact on Infant Neurodevelopment The baby cannot make much of its own, so it relies on what the mother eats and what is stored in her body. The baby’s brain stores DHA fastest from about week 29 to week 40,18PubMed Central. Maternal Docosahexaenoic Acid Status during Pregnancy and Its Impact on Infant Neurodevelopment so eating fish regularly in late pregnancy matters especially. In Japan, eating fish in early pregnancy was also linked to fewer birth defects of the gut.19British Journal of Nutrition. Fish consumption in early pregnancy and congenital gastrointestinal tract atresia in the Japan Environment and Children’s Study
Over-cautious advice can backfire. Many pregnant women say food rules leave them confused, afraid and guilty.20PubMed. Women’s experiences of dietary advice and dietary changes during pregnancy
A common pattern in pregnancy guidance is cooked, lower-mercury fish a couple of times a week. Oily fish such as salmon and sardines are among the richest sources of DHA and are also lower in mercury. Rotating between several kinds spreads out any contaminants while still supplying DHA.
If you dislike fish, ask your doctor about a prenatal vitamin that contains DHA. DHA supplements have helped keep mothers’ DHA levels up late in pregnancy.18PubMed Central. Maternal Docosahexaenoic Acid Status during Pregnancy and Its Impact on Infant Neurodevelopment Eggs enriched with omega-3 provide some DHA as well.
What to Do If You Already Ate Raw Fish
Don’t panic, because most single exposures cause no infection, though some infections cause no symptoms at all.21PubMed. Clinical management of women with listeriosis risk during pregnancy: a review of national guidelines Watch for fever, aches, or diarrhea over the next few weeks. If they appear, call your doctor or midwife rather than waiting for a scheduled checkup.
Doctors consider Listeria in any pregnant woman with a fever, especially with flu-like symptoms or an upset stomach.22PubMed Central. Listeriosis in Pregnancy: Diagnosis, Treatment, and Prevention They look at what you ate in the past month, so tell them what you ate and when.23PubMed Central. An Update Review on Listeria Infection in Pregnancy Catching the infection early and treating it with antibiotics improves the outcome for the baby.23PubMed Central. An Update Review on Listeria Infection in Pregnancy
Fever, chills, muscle aches, headache and tiredness are the usual early signs, and they can begin weeks after the meal. A baby that moves much less than usual is also a reason to call right away.
The infection is usually found with a blood test, but it shows up in only about 36 to 55% of women who have symptoms.23PubMed Central. An Update Review on Listeria Infection in Pregnancy So doctors may start treatment before the results come back.22PubMed Central. Listeriosis in Pregnancy: Diagnosis, Treatment, and Prevention Treatment is usually two weeks of high-dose amoxicillin, an antibiotic that is safe for the baby.23PubMed Central. An Update Review on Listeria Infection in Pregnancy

