Why Can’t We Live on Mars? A Scientific Explanation

Mars is the most viable target for near-term human colonization. However, the planet’s current environment is fundamentally hostile to unprotected human life, presenting lethal challenges that must be overcome for permanent settlement. The thin atmosphere, lack of a global magnetic field, weak gravity, and toxic surface material combine to make the Red Planet an immediate threat. Understanding these factors is the first step toward developing the necessary technologies for human survival.

The Perilous Martian Atmosphere

The Martian atmosphere presents a dual threat: unbreathable composition and dangerously low pressure. It consists almost entirely of carbon dioxide (about 95%), with virtually no free oxygen for respiration. An external supply or processing system is non-negotiable for survival.

The most immediate threat is the extremely low surface pressure, averaging only 6 to 7 millibars (less than one percent of Earth’s sea-level pressure). This pressure is far below the Armstrong Limit, the threshold where water boils at the normal human body temperature (63 millibars).

Because the Martian pressure is ten times lower than this limit, any exposed bodily fluid, such as saliva or blood, would instantly vaporize in a process called ebullism. This effect causes unconsciousness within seconds and leads to death shortly after, necessitating a fully pressurized suit for any extra-vehicular activity.

Unprotected from Cosmic and Solar Radiation

Mars lacks the two primary shields protecting life on Earth: a global magnetic field and a thick atmosphere. Billions of years ago, Mars lost its magnetosphere, leaving the surface exposed to high-energy particles streaming through space. Colonists would thus be subjected to continuous, elevated levels of space radiation.

The radiation environment consists of two main threats: Galactic Cosmic Rays (GCRs) and Solar Particle Events (SPEs). GCRs are high-energy protons and heavy atomic nuclei that originate outside the solar system and are highly penetrating. This constant exposure poses a long-term, chronic health risk, significantly increasing the lifetime risk of cancer and causing degenerative tissue effects and central nervous system decrements.

SPEs are intense, sudden bursts of protons released by the Sun. While shielding can protect against SPEs, the thin Martian atmosphere offers little defense. Prolonged exposure risks acute radiation sickness, which is immediately life-threatening. The cumulative radiation dose over a typical mission is estimated to be several times higher than the limit set for Earth-orbiting astronauts.

The Physiological Impact of Low Gravity

The gravity on Mars is approximately 0.38g. While this partial gravity is better than the microgravity of deep space, the long-term physiological effects are predicted to be harmful. The skeletal and muscular systems require the mechanical stress of Earth’s gravity to maintain mass and strength and would rapidly decondition.

Models predict that bone mineral density loss would continue even in 0.38g, potentially leading to severe osteoporosis over a multi-year mission. Muscle atrophy, particularly in the legs and back, would also occur, making it difficult for colonists to perform physical tasks or readapt to Earth’s gravity upon return.

The cardiovascular system is also expected to adapt poorly to the lower gravitational stress. On Earth, gravity requires the heart and blood vessels to work constantly to maintain circulation to the brain. In low gravity, this deconditioning could lead to orthostatic intolerance, causing a person to faint when standing up quickly. Furthermore, the effects of low gravity on reproduction and fetal development over generational timescales remain entirely unknown.

Toxic Regolith and Extreme Thermal Environment

The surface of Mars presents two additional hazards: chemically toxic soil and punishing temperature extremes. The Martian soil, or regolith, is not inert dirt but contains high concentrations of perchlorates, chlorine-containing compounds detected across the planet’s surface at levels up to 1%.

Perchlorates are toxic to humans because they competitively inhibit the uptake of iodide by the thyroid gland, potentially leading to serious illness or hormonal dysregulation upon ingestion or inhalation. The physical nature of the dust is also a concern, as the fine, sharp particles are easily suspended in the air. This dust can penetrate deep into the lungs, exacerbating the toxic effects and potentially causing pulmonary diseases.

The thermal environment adds a layer of engineering difficulty, with an average surface temperature around -63 °C (-81 °F). While temperatures near the equator can briefly reach 20 °C (68 °F) during the day, the planet’s thin atmosphere cannot retain heat. This lack of thermal inertia results in extreme diurnal temperature swings, where the temperature can plummet by 100 degrees Celsius or more after sunset. Any habitat or suit must provide continuous, energy-intensive heating and insulation.