Mary, Queen of Scots was beheaded in 1587 because Elizabeth I’s government convicted her of approving a plot to kill Elizabeth and take her throne.1Newberry Publications. Elizabeth I Yet the plot was less a surprise than an opportunity: Elizabeth’s spymaster had watched it grow and used it to trap her.2Wikipedia. Babington Plot Her death came from two kinds of betrayal at once, her own letters to the plotters and the secret service that read every one of them. Underneath lay an older problem. As a Catholic queen with a real claim to England’s crown, she had been a danger to Elizabeth for nearly twenty years before the axe fell.
Why Mary Was a Danger to Elizabeth
Mary was the granddaughter of Margaret Tudor, Henry VIII’s sister, which put her in the direct line to the English crown.3Discover Britain. Where was Mary, Queen of Scots kept in exile? She and Elizabeth were cousins once removed. Elizabeth was unmarried and childless, so the question of who would follow her never went away, and whoever did would decide whether England stayed Protestant. Mary returned to Scotland in August 1561 aged 18 and openly saw herself as Elizabeth’s rightful heir.4Sky HISTORY TV channel. Mary Queen of Scots: The legitimate heir to the English throne?
Many Catholics went further and considered Elizabeth illegitimate, since Henry VIII had married Anne Boleyn against the rules of the Catholic Church.5Discover Britain. Where was Mary, Queen of Scots kept in exile? To them Mary, not Elizabeth, was the true queen of England. In the 1500s a claim like this was not a vague quarrel. Henry VIII’s own will, backed by an Act of Parliament, had set out who should inherit, and it passed over the Stuart line. Mary’s claim rested on descent; Elizabeth’s rested on Parliament’s settlement and on actually holding the crown.
Religion made the rivalry dangerous. In Scotland the Protestant preacher John Knox attacked Mary for bringing back the Catholic Mass.6John Knox: On Rebellion. Knox and Mary Queen of Scots, September 1561 He wrote that one Mass frightened him more than ten thousand armed enemies landing in the realm.7Christian Heritage Edinburgh. John Knox and Mary, Queen of Scots Elizabeth’s ministers felt something similar. England had swung between Catholic and Protestant rulers within living memory, and Mary Tudor’s reign had seen Protestants burned, a memory they held close. A Catholic queen on the throne could undo the Protestant settlement.
French ties raised the stakes. Mary had been raised at the French court and had briefly been queen of France through her first marriage, so she was linked to a major Catholic power right across the Channel. A Mary on the English throne might bring French influence, or troops, to England’s doorstep, and England could be threatened from the north and from across the sea at once.
In 1570 the Pope issued an official decree aimed at removing Elizabeth in favour of her Catholic cousin Mary.8James Madison University. Her Majesty’s dignity: Secularization in the age of Reformation From then on, any Catholic plot against Elizabeth had a ready-made replacement queen. Elizabeth could not easily defuse this. She refused to name an heir, partly because a named successor would become a focus for plots against her. Naming Mary would have handed Catholics a future queen to wait for, and naming anyone else would have offended Mary’s supporters.
How Mary Became Elizabeth’s Prisoner
Scottish rebels imprisoned Mary at Lochleven Castle and forced her to give up her crown.9Aspects of History. The Captive Years of Mary, Queen of Scots She escaped and raised an army, but it was crushed at Langside near Glasgow.10Aspects of History. The Captive Years of Mary, Queen of Scots So on 16 May 1568 she crossed the Solway Firth into England, sure Elizabeth would help her regain her throne.11Discover Britain. Where was Mary, Queen of Scots kept in exile? Her companions thought the plan so foolish that they made her sign a letter saying she went against their advice.12Discover Britain. Where was Mary, Queen of Scots kept in exile? Soon after landing in Cumbria she was placed under house arrest.13Discover Britain. Where was Mary, Queen of Scots kept in exile?
Elizabeth neither freed her nor helped her, and each choice had a cost. Freeing her risked a Catholic rival rallying support in Scotland or France. Restoring her by force would anger Scotland’s Protestant government. Keeping her prisoner was the least bad option, though it kept plots alive. A scandal had followed Mary south as well: she was suspected of involvement in the murder of her second husband, Darnley, and the so-called Casket Letters were used as evidence against her. Their authenticity is still doubted.
Captivity was not a dungeon. Mary lived in castles and country houses, moving between several, with servants, a household of her own, and a degree of comfort suited to a queen. She was still guarded constantly, her movements restricted, and her visitors and letters were supposed to be controlled. Her keepers, such as the Earl of Shrewsbury, were burdened by the expense and strain of holding her.
Being a prisoner with a strong claim made her the person Catholic conspirators kept wanting to free and crown. Several plots before the Babington Plot, such as proposals to marry her to an English duke, had already involved her name, and each one taught Elizabeth’s ministers how dangerous she was.
Public opinion was worked on too. In 1571 Scottish lords’ accusations against her were printed as a pamphlet to turn English opinion against her.14University Collections. Mary Queen of Scots and literary propaganda It painted her as part of the wider Catholic threat, so English people would not rise to support her.15University Collections. Mary Queen of Scots and literary propaganda Propaganda against her ran from her fall in 1567 to her death in 1587, comparing her to murderous women of legend like Medea.16Huntington Library Quarterly. “This fatall Medea,” “this Clytemnestra”: Reading and the Detection of Mary Queen of Scots
The Babington Plot and the Trap Walsingham Set
The Babington Plot, named after the young Catholic Anthony Babington, combined three schemes. The plotters sought a Spanish invasion, the assassination of Elizabeth, and the rescue of Mary, perhaps while she rode near Chartley.17Wikipedia. Babington Plot Babington was a wealthy young gentleman who had once moved in Mary’s household circle and admired her. Priests and exiles encouraged his friends to treat the plan as a holy cause. They wanted outside backing because killing Elizabeth alone would not guarantee Mary’s rise. Mary’s approval therefore tied her directly to a plan to kill a reigning queen.
Elizabeth’s spymaster Sir Francis Walsingham discovered the plot and used it to entrap Mary and remove her as a claimant.18Wikipedia. Babington Plot Mary was confined at Chartley, and her letters were smuggled in and out inside waterproof containers in beer barrels delivered to the house. She and her supporters believed the route was secure, so they wrote openly. In fact a double agent passed each letter to Walsingham’s men to be copied and resealed before delivery, and neither side suspected anything.
Reading them required breaking her cipher. It replaced letters and common words with symbols, a system that looks secure but leaves patterns. The codebreaker Thomas Phelippes cracked it by spotting repeated letters.19Renaissance English History Podcast. Mary Queen of Scots’ Cipher, and the art of hiding messages Common letters appear most often in any language, so counting how often symbols repeated let him work out their meaning. He could also copy handwriting and forge additions, a skill that later fuelled doubts about the evidence. Phelippes was so overloaded that Walsingham had to wait for the letter proving her guilt.20Renaissance English History Podcast. Mary Queen of Scots’ Cipher, and the art of hiding messages When he finally decoded it, he drew a gallows on the page before passing it on.21Renaissance English History Podcast. Mary Queen of Scots’ Cipher, and the art of hiding messages
Was Mary guilty or framed? Most historians read her letter as approving the plot, including Elizabeth’s death. But Walsingham controlled the channel and let the plot run, and some accounts say spies actively encouraged it, which is debated.22warhistoryonline. 11 Reasons Why Spain Launched the Armada She was both guilty of agreeing and trapped by a government that wanted her gone.
The law made the trap deadly. The Bond of Association pledged its signers to kill anyone a plot against Elizabeth was meant to benefit.23Wikipedia. Bond of Association In 1585 it was partly written into law as the Act for the Queen’s Safety.24Wikipedia. Bond of Association It became the key legal basis for executing Mary in 1587.25Wikipedia. Bond of Association She was tried at Fotheringhay Castle in October 1586. She argued that as an anointed queen she was not subject to English courts, but the commissioners found her guilty of plotting Elizabeth’s death.
Why Elizabeth Hesitated to Sign
Two fears held Elizabeth back. She feared fury from Catholics in England, Scotland, and Europe.26maryqueenofscots.net. Why did Elizabeth I hesitate when signing the death warrant of Mary Queen of Scots? Catholic powers like France and Spain had reasons to be outraged at the killing of a Catholic queen, and she worried her enemies might use it as a pretext for open hostility. Her ministers argued that leaving Mary alive was the greater risk.
She also feared that executing an anointed queen would make her own throne less safe.27maryqueenofscots.net. Why did Elizabeth I hesitate when signing the death warrant of Mary Queen of Scots? Monarchs were crowned with holy oil in a religious ceremony, and people believed this set them apart as chosen by God. Executing one seemed to attack monarchy itself, not just one person. If a queen could be put to death by her subjects’ courts, the same might one day happen to her. So even after the guilty verdict she delayed signing for months.28BBC Bitesize. Mary is executed – Challenges to the rule of Queen Elizabeth I – Eduqas – GCSE History Revision
She looked for ways to be rid of the danger without personally ordering a death. Her officials even hinted that Mary’s keeper might quietly act on the Bond, which he found unacceptable.
In February 1587 she finally signed, but would not let the warrant be sent.29BBC Bitesize. Mary is executed – Challenges to the rule of Queen Elizabeth I – Eduqas – GCSE History Revision Her advisers sent it to Fotheringhay at once, and Mary was beheaded the next day.30Newberry Publications. Elizabeth I Cecil and the council had moved fast before she could change her mind. Elizabeth then claimed she never meant it to be carried out.31Newberry Publications. Elizabeth I Her anger let her tell foreign rulers she was not to blame, and historians debate whether her distress was real, political, or both. Secretary William Davison was sent to the Tower for 18 months.32BBC Bitesize. Mary is executed – Challenges to the rule of Queen Elizabeth I – Eduqas – GCSE History Revision William Cecil was briefly banned from court, mostly for show, then restored.33maryqueenofscots.net. Why did Elizabeth I hesitate when signing the death warrant of Mary Queen of Scots?
Mary’s Execution at Fotheringhay
Mary had been told the night before that she would die. She spent her last hours praying, writing letters, and making her will, and she gave small belongings to her servants so those closest to her would have keepsakes. In the morning she was led into the hall, where local gentry and officials waited. A black-draped scaffold stood in the castle’s Great Hall, with a block and stools for the witnessing earls.34Wikipedia. Execution of Mary, Queen of Scots
The Protestant Dean of Peterborough tried to lead prayers and urged her to repent in the Protestant way. Mary refused and prayed aloud in Latin, a public statement of her faith.
The executioner asked her forgiveness, and she said she forgave him, hoping he would end all her troubles.35Wikipedia. Execution of Mary, Queen of Scots She asked for her ladies to help with her clothing, as befit a queen. The executioners objected at first, but she told them she was not used to undressing before such company. Her ladies helped remove her outer clothes, showing crimson-brown sleeves, red being the Catholic colour of martyrdom.36Wikipedia. Execution of Mary, Queen of Scots She carried a crucifix and a Latin prayer book,37Historical Research. Visualizing the executions of British queens in early modern Europe and her ladies covered her eyes with a cloth.
Her last words were ‘Into thy hands, O Lord, I commend my spirit.’38Wikipedia. Execution of Mary, Queen of Scots The first blow struck the back of her head, and the second did not fully sever her neck.39Wikipedia. Execution of Mary, Queen of Scots When the executioner raised her head, her auburn hair proved to be a wig, and the head fell, showing short grey hair.40Wikipedia. Execution of Mary, Queen of Scots
What Mary’s Death Changed
Before dying she wrote to Henry III of France saying she was dying for her faith, not for treason.41History Today. Making a Martyr of Mary, Queen of Scots That letter helped build her lasting image as a Catholic martyr.42History Today. Making a Martyr of Mary, Queen of Scots Catholic writers repeated it and printed pictures of her death. The government charged her with plotting against the queen, a political crime, while Mary and her supporters framed the same event as persecution of her faith.
Spain began planning to invade England in 1585, two years before the execution.43tutor2u. Early Elizabethan England: Reasons for the Spanish Armada Philip II had hoped Mary might become a Catholic queen of England, which would have made conquest unnecessary. With Mary gone, only conquest could put a Catholic on England’s throne.44warhistoryonline. 11 Reasons Why Spain Launched the Armada Philip also claimed some right to the English throne himself, which gave his plans extra justification. Her death strengthened the case for the 1588 Armada rather than starting it, so the Armada was not simply revenge.
Her son James VI protested but did not break with Elizabeth. He stood to inherit England, which mattered more, and in 1603 he became James I of England, uniting the crowns.

