Athletes put black under their eyes mainly to cut the sun’s glare, the bright light that bounces off the cheeks and washes out what a player is trying to see. The greasy kind seems to help a little, while the popular stickers apparently do almost nothing for vision.1Yale News. Eye Black Grease More Effective at Reducing Glare and Improving Visual Contrast than Anti-Glare Stickers, Yale Researchers Find For many players, though, the real draw is the look and the feeling of going into battle, which is why it shows up even at night games.
Does Eye Black Actually Help You See
Eye doctors at Yale put it to a test. They had people read an eye chart in natural sunlight while wearing eye black grease, anti-glare stickers, or plain petroleum jelly standing in for no treatment.2Wikipedia. Eye black Jelly is shiny and greasy like eye black but not dark, so any difference points to the pigment rather than to people expecting it to help.
Only the black grease improved contrast sensitivity, the ability to see faint differences between light and dark.3Advances in Ophthalmology & Visual System. The ophthalmic science behind eyeblack grease and its use in professional and youth athletics People wearing it could make out lower-contrast letters on the chart than those wearing jelly.
The physics is plausible. Sunlight hits the cheekbones just below the eyes and bounces upward, and that scattered light adds a haze over whatever the player is looking at. A dark, matte layer soaks up light instead of reflecting it, the same reason camera lenses and gun sights are dark inside.
The improvement over petroleum jelly was modest. Still, in sports where a fast ball has to be picked out against a bright sky, small contrast gains matter.
One study isn’t the final word. The test was small and done in one setting with an eye chart, not a real game, and nobody measured whether players actually hit or catch better. Fewer than half of eye doctors and athletic trainers in one survey believed eye black works.4CommonKnowledge. Optometric trends in sports vision: Sports vision utilization entering the new millenium
And there are times it can’t help at all. On cloudy days or at night, little sunlight bounces off the cheeks. Under stadium lights the glare comes mostly from above, not off the face. Eye black also does nothing for glare coming straight into the eyes, where a hat brim or sunglasses work better.
Grease Versus Stickers
Anti-glare stickers showed no improvement in contrast sensitivity over petroleum jelly.5Yale News. Eye Black Grease More Effective at Reducing Glare and Improving Visual Contrast than Anti-Glare Stickers, Yale Researchers Find When people used both eyes together, grease beat stickers directly.6PubMed. The ability of periorbitally applied antiglare products to improve contrast sensitivity in conditions of sunlight exposure A player who wants a real glare benefit should choose the grease.
Stickers took over anyway. They are usually a patented fabric strip with an adhesive backing,7Beach Eye Medical Group. Why Do Athletes Use Eye Black? so they go on in seconds and leave little residue when peeled off after a game.8Beach Eye Medical Group. Why Do Athletes Use Eye Black? Their flat surface also makes it easy to print logos or messages on them.
For a bright afternoon game where glare matters, grease is the better pick based on the testing. For a night game, a team photo day, or a child who dislikes greasy skin, a sticker costs little in vision because there was little sun to block anyway.
If you go with grease, apply a solid strip on the cheekbone directly under each eye. Keep it away from the eyelids so sweat doesn’t carry it into the eyes. A stick goes on more evenly than smearing from a pot with your fingers. Afterward, soap, oil, or makeup remover takes it off.
The War Paint Effect
Players wear eye black during night and indoor games, where there is no sun to block.9Advances in Ophthalmology & Visual System. The ophthalmic science behind eyeblack grease and its use in professional and youth athletics Many athletes say they wear it for an aggressive look and a psychological edge.10Advances in Ophthalmology & Visual System. The ophthalmic science behind eyeblack grease and its use in professional and youth athletics Some athletes say they wear it purely for looks.11CommonKnowledge. Optometric trends in sports vision: Sports vision utilization entering the new millenium Lacrosse star Charlotte North calls it war paint, wears it only on game days, and says it strikes fear in opponents.12Front Office Sports. How Eye Black Became ‘War Paint’ Baseball star Bryce Harper has said he would wear it even on a cloudy day.13Advances in Ophthalmology & Visual System. The ophthalmic science behind eyeblack grease and its use in professional and youth athletics Little League World Series players said the vision benefit had nothing to do with it, and one said it made him feel scarier.14Advances in Ophthalmology & Visual System. The ophthalmic science behind eyeblack grease and its use in professional and youth athletics
A game-day ritual can help in its own right. Routines like taping wrists or putting on eye black signal to the brain that it’s time to compete, the same way a lucky shirt or a warm-up song does. Feeling more confident can sharpen focus and reduce nerves, and that benefit is real to the athlete even if no glare is blocked.
For a young player, the appeal is usually simple: favorite pros wear it. Wearing it for fun or confidence is harmless if it’s kept out of the eyes, and parents who want the glare benefit can choose grease for sunny afternoon games.
What Eye Black Is Made Of
Modern eye black grease is a mix of beeswax, paraffin wax, and carbon soot.15Beach Eye Medical Group. Why Do Athletes Use Eye Black? Carbon soot is the pigment; it is very dark and absorbs light instead of bouncing it back. The two waxes give the mix body so it can be shaped into a stick and spread in a layer, and they make it water-resistant so it clings to skin through a sweaty game. That makes it close to a waxy makeup stick, which is why makeup remover takes it off well. Babe Ruth is often credited with an early version in the 1930s, smearing soot from a burnt cork under his eyes.16Front Office Sports. How Eye Black Became ‘War Paint’ on the Field
Wax-based grease is generally gentle, but anyone with sensitive skin can test a small spot first. Sticker adhesive can irritate some skin when pulled off quickly. Keeping eye black out of the eyes matters more than the ingredients, and washing it off fully after games helps avoid clogged pores.
Rules About Eye Black Messages
Writing messages on eye black grew popular after college football stars Reggie Bush and Tim Tebow did it.17ESPN. NCAA bans eye black messages Tebow was known for writing Bible verses on his.18Baptist Press. Why Do Athletes Put Black Under Their Eyes?
Then college football banned eye black with messages or symbols.19The Florida Times-Union. NCAA bans eye-black messages and will implement stiff penalty for taunting Any eye black worn must now be solid black with no words, numbers, logos, or other symbols.20Baptist Press. Why Do Athletes Put Black Under Their Eyes? The NCAA said eye black was allowed to shade the eyes from the sun, and messages took away from that purpose.21The Florida Times-Union. NCAA bans eye-black messages and will implement stiff penalty for taunting
The ban applies to college football. Youth leagues and high schools set their own rules, so players should check their league’s equipment rules before decorating eye black. A plain black strip is allowed almost everywhere.
The Cheetah Comparison
Cheetahs have black stripes running from their eyes down the sides of their faces.22Cheetah Conservation Fund Canada. For Cheetahs Speed Is Important, but So Is Eyesight The dark lines start at the inner corner of each eye and run toward the mouth, like streaks left by tears, standing out against the pale, tan coat.
These marks are thought to keep the sun’s glare away from the eyes on bright open plains.23Wildlife ACT. Why Do Cheetah Have Tear Marks? Cheetahs hunt in open grassland in daylight, with little shade, and they chase fast prey over long, open ground. Less glare would help keep that prey visible against a bright background, so a cheetah can stay focused during a high-speed chase.24Wildlife ACT. Why Do Cheetah Have Tear Marks? The comparison only goes so far: the stripes’ purpose is an explanation rather than a measured result, so the cheetah is an illustration, not proof that eye black works.

