Why Do Doctors Slap Babies? The Truth About Newborn Care

The moments following birth represent a rapid transition for a newborn adjusting from the womb to breathing air. Healthcare providers immediately focus on supporting this transition, ensuring the baby is warm and breathing effectively. This initial period involves swift, standardized assessment and gentle intervention focused on the baby’s safety. The procedures used are highly regulated and designed to encourage the body’s natural response to life outside the mother.

The Myth vs. Modern Practice

The popular image of a doctor forcefully “slapping” a newborn is a pervasive misconception that does not reflect modern medical care. Current neonatal resuscitation guidelines explicitly caution against injurious actions like slapping, shaking, or suspending an infant. The focus is instead on providing gentle physical stimulation to encourage the baby to take its first breaths.

The primary method of stimulation is vigorous drying of the baby with a warm towel immediately after birth. This action helps prevent hypothermia and provides the sensory input necessary to initiate spontaneous respiration and crying. If drying alone is insufficient, medical staff may rub the baby’s back or trunk, or lightly flick the soles of the feet. This tactile stimulation is usually enough to prompt the necessary respiratory effort and a successful transition.

The Apgar Scoring System Explained

The standard for evaluating a newborn’s health immediately after birth is the Apgar scoring system, developed by Dr. Virginia Apgar in 1952. This assessment is performed twice: at one minute after birth to determine immediate transition needs, and again at five minutes to gauge the effectiveness of initial interventions. The system examines five physiological criteria, each assigned a score of zero, one, or two.

The five criteria form a mnemonic: Appearance, Pulse, Grimace, Activity, and Respiration. Each criterion is scored based on the following:

  • Appearance refers to the baby’s skin color; a score of two is given for a completely pink body, indicating good oxygen circulation.
  • Pulse score is based on the heart rate; over 100 beats per minute earns the maximum two points.
  • Grimace assesses reflex irritability, which is the baby’s response to stimulation, such as light suctioning, where a cough or sneeze scores highest.
  • Activity measures muscle tone; a score of two is given for strong, active movement and flexed limbs.
  • Respiration evaluates the breathing effort, where a vigorous cry is considered optimal and earns two points.

The total score ranges from zero to ten. A score of seven to ten is reassuring and indicates the baby is adapting well to life outside the womb. A score below seven suggests the baby may need support to complete the transition. A low score at the one-minute mark is common, especially following a difficult delivery, and does not predict long-term health issues. The five-minute score is a more reliable indicator of the newborn’s overall condition. If the score remains below seven at the five-minute mark, the assessment will be repeated every five minutes for up to twenty minutes.

Historical Roots of the Misconception

The idea that a baby must be slapped to start breathing is rooted in historical medical practices and their portrayal in media. Before the Apgar system was globally recognized and implemented in the mid-20th century, methods for stimulating a non-breathing infant were arbitrary and often forceful. These older techniques sometimes included holding the newborn upside down and giving a sharp slap to the buttocks or back.

While intended to shock the baby into breathing, these actions were riskier and lacked the standardization of modern care. These visually impactful scenes were frequently used in films and television to signify the successful arrival of a baby, cementing the image in popular culture. The “slap” became a shorthand for the loud cry that signals a baby’s first successful breath, even after the practice was abandoned by the medical community.

Steps Taken When a Newborn Needs Support

When a baby’s transition is sluggish, indicated by a low Apgar score or weak respiratory effort, gentle stimulation is the first step. If the baby fails to respond to drying and rubbing within the first minute, healthcare providers move quickly to a measured sequence of interventions. The initial focus is on opening the airway, which may involve positioning the head in a neutral alignment and gently suctioning mucus from the mouth and nose.

If the baby is still not breathing or has a heart rate below 100 beats per minute, the next step is to initiate positive pressure ventilation (PPV). This involves using a small mask over the baby’s mouth and nose to gently deliver air into the lungs, helping to inflate them and establish functional residual capacity. This measured delivery of air is a controlled medical procedure.

In rare instances where the heart rate remains below 60 beats per minute despite effective ventilation, chest compressions are initiated, often with continued ventilation. Advanced steps, such as administering medications like epinephrine, are reserved for newborns who fail to respond to the initial steps of resuscitation. These modern interventions are part of a standardized, controlled protocol designed to support the newborn without resorting to harmful force.