Why Do My Toenails Keep Falling Off?

Toenail detachment, medically known as nail shedding, can be surprising and sometimes painful. Detachment usually falls into two categories: onycholysis, where the nail lifts from the tip, or onychomadesis, which involves shedding starting closer to the nail root. While alarming, this represents the body’s natural response to protect the delicate tissue underneath. Understanding the underlying trigger is the first step in preventing recurrence.

Common External and Local Causes

The most frequent reasons for toenail separation involve mechanical stress and local infections. Physical trauma is a major factor, ranging from acute, heavy impact to repetitive micro-trauma. Acute injury often leads to a subungual hematoma, a collection of blood under the nail plate that puts pressure on the nail bed, eventually forcing the nail to detach.

Repetitive trauma is common in athletes, particularly runners, or individuals wearing ill-fitting shoes. When toes constantly press against the shoe’s end, the repeated force causes the nail to lift gradually from the underlying bed (onycholysis). Tight hiking or safety boots often cause this chronic separation, especially on downhill sections where the foot slides forward.

Fungal infections represent the primary biological cause for detachment. The fungus invades the nail structure and nail bed, causing the nail plate to thicken, become discolored, and develop a crumbly texture. As the infection progresses, fungal growth undermines the bond between the nail and the bed, resulting in progressive lifting and shedding. This infection requires specific antifungal treatment to prevent recurrence.

Systemic Health Conditions and Medications

Sometimes toenail detachment signals an internal issue rather than a local problem. Certain autoimmune and inflammatory skin conditions, such as psoriasis, affect the nail matrix and nail bed, disrupting normal nail growth. Psoriasis can cause pitting, discoloration, and characteristic separation of the nail plate.

Hormonal imbalances, such as hyperthyroidism or hypothyroidism, can slow nail growth or cause the nail plate to become brittle and detach. Severe nutritional deficiencies, particularly a lack of iron or zinc, can also manifest in nail changes. These systemic causes require a medical diagnosis and treatment of the underlying condition.

Medications are another significant cause, particularly chemotherapy agents and certain antibiotics, like tetracyclines. Some drugs cause photo-onycholysis, where separation occurs only after the feet are exposed to sunlight. If detachment occurs soon after starting a new medication, consult a healthcare provider to explore potential drug side effects.

Immediate Care and Prevention

If a toenail detaches, the immediate priority is protecting the exposed, sensitive nail bed underneath. Gently clean the area with soap and water, and apply a topical antibiotic ointment to prevent secondary infection. Do not forcefully pull off any remaining portion of the nail plate, as this can cause further damage to the nail bed.

Cover the exposed area with a sterile, non-adhesive bandage until the tissue hardens, which typically takes a few days to a week. For prevention, focusing on footwear is paramount; ensure shoes provide ample space in the toe box to prevent micro-trauma during physical activity. Proper nail hygiene involves trimming nails straight across, rather than rounding the edges, and keeping them short to minimize lifting leverage.

If separation is accompanied by signs of infection, such as increasing redness, swelling, pus, or throbbing pain, professional medical attention is necessary. A doctor should also be consulted if detachment recurs frequently, affects multiple nails without obvious trauma, or if a systemic cause is suspected. Early intervention can prevent the condition from worsening.

Understanding Nail Regrowth

Replacing a lost toenail is a slow process, reflecting the natural growth rate of the nail matrix. A completely detached toenail takes approximately 12 to 18 months to grow back fully from base to tip. Toenails grow much slower than fingernails, averaging about 1.62 millimeters per month.

During this extended regrowth period, the new nail is fragile and the underlying nail bed is vulnerable to injury. Continue protecting the area with clean socks and properly fitting shoes. The new nail may temporarily appear uneven, discolored, or ridged as it begins to emerge. Consistent protection and patience are required for a full and healthy regeneration.